The beads
17,283 words12 subsections11 tablesPlan version 1.1
On this page12
These are the seed for conversion with br. Titles name the artifact. "Done when" is one observable, usually with a
negative control: a planted failure the bead must catch. Beads of M0 to M5 are tasks. Beads of M6, M7 and M8 are
epics, one per frontier item and one group for the ten-fold tournament; an epic is split into tasks when its milestone
opens, and part of its done-condition is that a short plan exists and its pilot has run (§0.7). Each milestone ends
with an exit review performed by a fresh-context session that did not implement the work. Every dependency points to a
lower-numbered bead. Every bead inherits §0.2 and the false-progress guards of §38.
How to read a row (DESIGN):
- A gate identifier in "Done when" means the gate's recorded value together with its caught negative control, as defined in the chapter that owns the gate and listed in §40. "Rows of", "on the referee" and "for the M2 verbs" restrict the bead to the part of the gate that can be measured when the bead closes. The gate's PASS is recorded when the last bead that cites it closes. Admission gates (INT-…) are read the same way, with the admission record of §33.6 as the value.
- "Decided" after a kill gate means that its trigger was evaluated on measured values and that the outcome, either way, is recorded as an ADR. A kill gate that fires replaces the bead's capability by the fallback named in advance. The bead then closes on the fallback, and its dependents are re-read against it (§45.11).
- Numbers in a done-condition are TARGET thresholds or exact known answers taken from the owning chapters. None is a measurement.
- Placement. A bead sits in the milestone that §43 assigns to its mechanism. Where a gate table names a different earliest milestone than the bead that closes the gate, §45.10 lists the difference, and the value is recorded when the bead closes.
- Upstream work is bead work. A change to a sibling is a bead of this graph with the label
upstream, done in the sibling's repository under its own rules and mirrored as a bead in the sibling's tracker (§33.8). BD-037 opens the upstream work items of Appendix F, the two P0 items are part of BD-008 and BD-023, and every bead that stands on a sibling has an interim posture that holds until the upstream change lands. - Numbering. The list is numbered from BD-001 so that the numbering is a topological order. BD-001 to BD-024 keep the subjects they had in version 0.2, with corrected content, so that §46 reads against the same numbers. Numbers above BD-024 are new assignments.
45.1 M0: spine and airlock
M0 retires the risks that could invalidate the architecture, with the smallest amount of code. Beyond the workspace,
the airlock and the one-kernel spike, it measures the rival before anything is built against it, re-runs the plan-time
pilots so that their numbers are this repository's own, and admits the four reported foundation defects as tests. M0
also chooses the one toolchain T of the whole build graph, brings fastmcp_rust onto it and aligns the consumed siblings
on one asupersync version, as upstream work in those repositories (§33.13). The MCP server is a member of the core
graph and runs verbs in process. frob-cert also builds alone: it has no dependency and its own stable compiler.
| Bead | Title | Depends on | Done when |
|---|---|---|---|
| BD-001 | Core workspace skeleton: Cargo.toml, one rust-toolchain.toml for the whole build graph naming candidate (a) of §33.13 as the provisional T, .cargo/config.toml with the build-identity variable, franken-stack.lock and its first resolution receipt, the asupersync patch entry, FrankenSQLite profile overrides |
— | cargo check is green on the empty workspace through the offload shim, and the receipt hash recomputes from the lock |
| BD-002 | Companion documents: AGENTS.md, README.md with a generated honest-status table, DEPENDENCY_ADMISSION.md, schema-valid registries (empty except formats.toml with its thirteen rows), the schemas for demo.yaml and contract.toml |
BD-001 | The status table regenerates from registries/gates.toml; a gate with no measured value prints as open, never as passed |
| BD-003 | xtask check-layers and check-deps |
BD-001 | A deliberate upward edge, an intra-layer edge against rank and a forbidden dependency each fail |
| BD-004 | xtask check-stack, check-contracts, check-unsafe, check-generated; the test that xtask has exactly six subcommands |
BD-003 | GATE-WS-01: 7 of 7 plants caught, each by the check that owns it and by no other; GATE-WS-04: the six checks finish within 60 s on a warm tree |
| BD-005 | frob-core: identities and hashing, evidence classes, the claim-product type, the no-authorization flags, the refusal type and registry loader, the qty re-export module |
BD-001 | An unknown refusal code is a load-time error; converting a claim product to one of its factors fails to compile; a flag has no setter |
| BD-006 | INT-FSIM-01 and the core row of INT-TOOLCHAIN-01: path dependencies on fs-ga, fs-mbd, fs-contact, fs-time, fs-query with the root patch, profile and build-identity settings, built on candidate (a) for T and, if FrankenSim cannot yet build there, on candidate (b) |
BD-001 | An admission record with the command, its output, the commit, cold and warm check times, peak memory and package count, and the candidate on which FrankenSim builds; with the build-identity variable unset the build fails closed |
| BD-007 | frob-fsim v0: RefereeDynamics over fs_mbd::articulated; the G1 digest test |
BD-006 | The digest equals the one computed inside FrankenSim at the pinned commit; a perturbed input changes it |
| BD-008 | INT-ASUP-01 wired into check-stack, and upstream work item FD-ASUP-01: FrankenSim's constellation, FrankenTorch and fastmcp_rust aligned on one published asupersync version by changes in those repositories |
BD-004, BD-006 | cargo tree -d evidence recorded for each workspace, showing one package at the one published version; a seeded second asupersync version fails; each sibling change has landed through that sibling's own gates and has its mirrored bead |
| BD-009 | INT-FSQL-01: ledger open, write, forced kill, recover | BD-006 | The forced-kill test passes 100 times |
| BD-010 | frob-lie: traits; SO(3) and SE(3) over fs-ga; the PO-MARROW-01 fixture |
BD-006 | Bit-equal on 1,000 transforms produced by fs-ga |
| BD-011 | frob-lie: Cayley and exponential retractions with derivatives; laws for SO(3) and SE(3); the coadjoint convention of §11.2 |
BD-010 | GATE-MARROW-01 rows for these groups; a planted reversed ad* fails the free-body known answer π̇ = (0, 0, −1) |
| BD-012 | frob-lie: SO(2) as a unit complex number with a turn counter |
BD-011 | PO-MARROW-03 over 10⁹ steps |
| BD-013 | Shared dialect prelude v0 for CUDA and Metal; the dialect lint | BD-001 | The lint rejects a built-in transcendental, a floating-point atomic and a construct that permits fusing a multiply with an add |
| BD-014 | KernelBackend trait, the kernel manifest with its stage signature, and the batch-cpu harness |
BD-005 | A trivial kernel runs through the harness with a receipt; a manifest whose write footprint aliases an undeclared buffer is refused |
| BD-015 | INT-CUDA-01 and spark/frob-spark-cuda v0: driver load, NVRTC compile, cache, launch |
BD-013, BD-014 | A kernel runs on both GPUs of trj; the admission record states whether the pinned cudarc binds graph capture and stream-ordered pools |
| BD-016 | INT-FT-01 and spark/frob-spark-metal v0 over the ft-kernel-metal gateway, with FrankenTorch's block patch repeated at the annex root |
BD-013, BD-014 | A kernel runs on this Mac and matches a Rust loop bit for bit on 10⁶ quaternions; admission record |
| BD-017 | spark.probe: the IEEE probe kernels and report |
BD-015, BD-016 | GATE-SPARK-01 results stored as device evidence for both families; the contraction detector fires on a planted fused multiply-add |
| BD-018 | frob-kir v0: straight-line programs, common-subexpression elimination, Rust and dialect emitters, the dimension checker |
BD-005 | Emits K-cay-step; a seeded dimension violation is rejected |
| BD-019 | INT-FSYM-01 and derive/frob-derive v0: derive K-cay-step and K-normalize |
BD-018 | Regeneration reproduces the checked-in sources bit for bit |
| BD-020 | GATE-SPARK-00 and INT-FSIM-11: one dialect source for K-cay-step on batch-cpu, CUDA and Metal |
BD-015, BD-016, BD-019 | Agreement inside the class, recorded in the divergence ledger; a one-ulp change planted in one prelude is reported |
| BD-021 | frob-lemma v0: claims and instance certificates for T-01, T-03 and T-04 on the M0 kernels, checked by FrankenSymPy |
BD-019 | The three identities certify and a mutated coefficient is rejected; constructing Proved evidence outside frob-lemma fails to compile |
| BD-022 | frob-verbs v0 and the frob skeleton: registry loader, the envelope with claim product and flags, exit codes including 8 (accepted and still running), doctor, capabilities, schema, robot-docs |
BD-005 | GATE-TETHER-03 on these verbs |
| BD-023 | INT-FMCP-01 and upstream work item FD-FMCP-01: fastmcp_rust brought onto T in its own repository (its toolchain file and, where T requires it, its declared rust-version changed; its test suite and MCP conformance checks passing on T); surface/frob-mcp as a member of the core workspace, built on fastmcp_rust, linking frob-verbs, generated from the registry for the M0 verbs and running them in process |
BD-022 | fastmcp_rust's own suite and conformance checks are green on T at the pinned commit; frob-mcp builds in the core graph on T with exactly one asupersync package (cargo tree -d shows no duplicate), lists the tools generated from the verb registry, and passes the MCP protocol smoke test over stdio and HTTP |
| BD-024 | sim.run --tier referee for the built-in G1; digest and T0 telemetry to the ledger |
BD-007, BD-009, BD-022 | A fresh session reproduces the M0 artifact from the recorded command |
| BD-025 | frob-conformance v0: tiers G0 to G5 and the negative-control registry |
BD-005 | A gate registered without a negative control fails the registry check (GATE-GAUNT-01 for M0) |
| BD-026 | frob-cert with an empty dependency table and its own stable toolchain file: canonical JSON reader, BLAKE3, exact integer and rational arithmetic, outward-rounded intervals; the frob-verify binary |
BD-001 | GATE-WS-03: cargo tree -p frob-cert prints one line, the copied directory builds with no network access, and a system-call trace of an audit shows no socket and no child process; BLAKE3 matches the published vectors |
| BD-027 | .frobcert bundles for instance certificates: the writer in frob-lemma against the schema, the poly-identity and rational-ldlt checkers in frob-cert, and prove.kernel, prove.verify, prove.list |
BD-021, BD-022, BD-026 | GATE-LEMMA-00: the M0 certificates replay in frob-verify, which closes INT-FSYM-01; GATE-LEMMA-06: a bundle with a flag set to true is rejected |
| BD-028 | INT-FT-02: resident buffers and device completion receipts through the Metal gateway | BD-016 | A buffer stays resident across two command buffers and the receipt comes from the device; a device tag alone earns zero operator coverage |
| BD-029 | spark.fingerprint: the hardware fingerprint of both machines (frob.fingerprint/1) |
BD-015, BD-016 | GATE-SPARK-07 |
| BD-030 | Exact-integer kernel class probe: K-x-pred and K-g-pred with exact fallback on the docking-boundary screen of 65,536 rows |
BD-015, BD-016, BD-018 | GATE-SPARK-08: identical bytes on batch-cpu, both RTX 4090 and Metal; the unguarded single-precision kernel shows false admissions and is rejected as a strict predicate |
| BD-031 | INT-TOOLCHAIN-01: the matrix of §33.12 over the four nightlies in play, the choice of T and its record in franken-stack.lock and rust-toolchain.toml, the fs-qty coupling test, and the decision on frob-units |
BD-003, BD-005, BD-006, BD-016, BD-019, BD-023, BD-026 | Every cell of the matrix has a recorded result and every row passes on T; the choice of T is an ADR that names the sibling pins a toolchain train must move; a direct fs_qty import outside frob-core and frob-fsim fails check-deps; the frob-units decision is an ADR |
| BD-032 | INT-FSIM-02 and INT-FSIM-03: first admission tests of the fs-ga Lie façades and of fs-mbd articulated dynamics |
BD-007 | Power ⟨wrench, twist⟩ is frame-invariant to 10⁻¹² relative and a reversed adjoint fails at least three fixtures; a two-joint arm's accelerations match differentiated energy to 10⁻¹⁰ |
| BD-033 | Foundation-defect admission INT-FSIM-05: the planar_drive near-straight case, and the independent chord formula in frob-conformance |
BD-007, BD-025 | The record states whether zero translation reproduces at the pin; the independent formula returns the chord (0, 2/π) m and one metre over 400 steps at heading 32 rad |
| BD-034 | Foundation-defect admission INT-FSIM-06: three PPO probes (the clip branch for both advantage signs, the critic gradient from the current output, packed sequences across a reset) | BD-025 | Each probe has a recorded result against the sibling source at the pin, and an implementation carrying each planted defect fails its probe |
| BD-035 | Foundation-defect admission INT-FSIM-04 and INT-FSIM-07 (refusal half): the fixed-witness sustained step and the contact capacity, through the airlock | BD-007 | The flat-to-edge-to-top transition returns the typed refusal at the pin; a set of 22 contacts returns the capacity refusal; a thin step between clear endpoint poses is detected on 1,000 of 1,000 sweeps |
| BD-036 | Foundation-defect admission INT-FNP-01 and INT-FNP-02: the typed stride converter at the interchange boundary | BD-005 | An array file reads back identically; the 2×2 case reads element 3, and the verbatim stride copy that reads element 12 is refused |
| BD-037 | The upstream work items of Appendix F opened as beads labelled upstream in this graph and mirrored in the sibling trackers (FD-FSIM-10 to -16, FD-FNP-01 and the others on file; the two P0 items are in BD-008 and BD-023) |
BD-016, BD-023, BD-033, BD-034, BD-035, BD-036 | Each upstream work item has its fixture, its interim posture, its switch-over rule and an identifier in registries/upstream.toml, a bead here and a mirrored bead in its sibling's tracker |
| BD-038 | INT-FSIM-18: the worker-process fallback exercised before it is needed (frob-fsim-worker, the remote mode of the airlock) |
BD-007 | The G1 digest through the worker equals the in-process digest; a worker at a different pin is refused (FROB-REF-791) |
| BD-039 | The incumbent harness as an out-of-process oracle: pinned revisions, the strongest warm configurations, the disclosure block | BD-001, BD-029 | The pinned incumbents run on trj from a recorded environment; a changed revision changes the harness identity |
| BD-040 | Parity baseline on trj: the incumbent phase ledger for cold start, physics and full step on workloads Q and H, time to threshold on one and two cards, and edit to first step for a parameter edit and a topology edit |
BD-039 | The trj rows of GATE-SPARK-21 are recorded under the disclosure block; each published figure of §36.3 is reproduced within 20% or the difference is explained in writing |
| BD-041 | The plan-time pilot for the cart docking closed form, re-run from the reproduction bundle with two gains and with three | BD-025 | 561 cells give 344 admitted, 217 excluded and nine on the boundary, and every late-packet cell is excluded; the gain 33/32 makes exact docking unsatisfiable with worst error at least 1/65 m |
| BD-042 | The plan-time pilot for the static stance family, re-run from the reproduction bundle | BD-025 | 11,520 of 11,520 states agree and the half-width is 3/14 m; the support-polygon-plus-capacity screen wrongly accepts 1,596 bodies; equal passive springs give (175, 115, 85, 25) N |
| BD-043 | The remaining plan-time pilots of §25.22, re-run and recorded (probe, pad family, sensor aliasing, pusher and its timing ceiling, labels, decision reuse, shared bus, admission fixtures, sill) | BD-041, BD-042 | Every row reproduces its recorded result or the difference is written into the review log; the pusher ceiling of about 1.46 is recomputed before any speed figure is quoted |
| BD-044 | M0 exit review by a fresh-context session that did not implement the work; KILL-FSIM and KILL-MCP decisions recorded as ADRs; the state of the two P0 upstream work items recorded | BD-002, BD-008, BD-012, BD-017, BD-020, BD-024, BD-027, BD-028, BD-030, BD-031, BD-032, BD-037, BD-038, BD-040, BD-043 | Every gate of M0 has a recorded value and a caught negative control (GATE-GAUNT-01) |
45.2 M1: referee studio and first mission slice
Everything in M1 runs on the CPU. A gate that also has device rows is closed here on the referee only, and its device rows close at M2. The mission slice (BD-126 to BD-136) exercises the mission query, the clock contract, the certificate bundle and the offline auditor before any GPU work exists.
| Bead | Title | Depends on | Done when |
|---|---|---|---|
| BD-045 | frob-lie: SE(2), SE₂(3), SE₂₊ₖ(3), product groups |
BD-011, BD-012 | GATE-MARROW-01 complete: laws pass on 10⁶ cases each inside the ulp bounds; a planted error in the SE(2) exponential's Jacobian is caught |
| BD-046 | frob-lie: joint subgroups, Hervé classification (T-11), generated joint maps |
BD-011 | Each of the twelve classes is recognized from a basis; a non-closed basis is reported as a product |
| BD-047 | Frame-typed transforms, twists and wrenches; the three typed maps between frames (§11.3) | BD-010 | Mismatched frames fail to compile; the planar 2R fixture gives torques (−3, −3) N·m and −0.3 W by both routes, and the lower-three-rows shortcut, which gives (0, 0), is caught |
| BD-048 | frob-algebra: finite groups from generators, classes, characters, projectors (algebra.irreps) |
BD-005 | GATE-MARROW-02 |
| BD-049 | frob-algebra: orbits, Burnside counts, subgroup lattices, wreath products (algebra.orbits) |
BD-048 | The counts 86,185, 500,500 and 27 are exact; a wrong cycle index is caught |
| BD-050 | frob-algebra: the Cone trait; orthant, second-order and semidefinite cones |
BD-005 | Cone laws pass; a planted non-idempotent projection is caught |
| BD-051 | frob-algebra: the inertia cone and the mass-support predicate |
BD-050 | Round trip; a matrix one eigenvalue below zero is rejected; the 1 kg part declared inside a 0.10 m sphere is refused (FROB-REF-106) |
| BD-052 | frob-algebra: posets, antichains, Kleene iteration |
BD-005 | GB-03's closed form is reproduced; a divergent loop is reported infeasible |
| BD-053 | Exact predicates and guarded single precision as kernel classes: predicate typing, the select lint and error-bound derivation in frob-kir |
BD-030 | Single-precision 0.3, 0.4, 0.5 in x² + y² ≤ z² returns the exact sign; PO-MARROW-06 holds for each guarded predicate; an unguarded strict predicate fails the lint |
| BD-054 | frob-design: the term model, schema frob.design/1, the seven canonical-form rules, DesignId |
BD-005, BD-031 | Canonicalization is idempotent; the hash is equal on Linux and macOS; a duplicate key refuses |
| BD-055 | .fbot fields: fills with shell thickness and no default fill, budgets, levers, locks, the power bus, sensors, payloads, symmetry assertions |
BD-054 | A body with no fill refuses; a shell thicker than half the Region's smallest dimension refuses (FROB-REF-105); a lever outside its bounds refuses (FROB-REF-111) |
| BD-056 | Constructors: attach, chain, serial, mirror, radial, scale, replace, closure |
BD-054 | mirror equals its hand-expanded form; constructor terms stay unexpanded in the canonical bytes |
| BD-057 | The S-expression view and design.view |
BD-055, BD-056 | GATE-SKEL-05; KILL-SKEL-SEXPR decided |
| BD-058 | Typed edits with preconditions, inverses and declared symmetry effects (design.edit) |
BD-056 | An edit and its inverse return the same DesignId |
| BD-059 | Design patches and versioning: design.patch, schema frob.design.patch/1, expected parent, idempotency key, schema migration |
BD-058 | GATE-SKEL-08 |
| BD-060 | .fmodule: the module format and its port contract (mechanical, electrical, thermal, signal and contact ports; parameters); module.list, module.show, module.check |
BD-055, BD-056 | A reversed port sign refuses; a module digest mismatch refuses; a contract check that adds peak currents fails the shared-bus fixture |
| BD-061 | frob-model: the kinematic functor, RobotModel, the referee lowering |
BD-007, BD-032, BD-046, BD-047, BD-056 | A template quadruped's forward kinematics runs on the referee |
| BD-062 | Geometry and inertia functor: Regions, materials, the fill rule with shell moments as a difference of solids, primitive fitting with recorded error | BD-051, BD-055, BD-061 | The worked torso weighs 22.7 kg read as solid and 1.92 kg as a 2.5 mm shell; PO-SKEL-02 holds exactly; INV-SKEL-03 on every archetype shipped |
| BD-063 | Memoized incremental compilation, with the invalidation set returned by an edit | BD-058, BD-061 | GATE-SKEL-02 |
| BD-064 | Design lints with ranked repairs as typed edits | BD-058 | Each lint has a fixture that triggers it and one that does not |
| BD-065 | frob-io: the in-house XML reader; URDF import with a loss report |
BD-061 | Reference robots import; a planted dropped field appears in the report with its file and line |
| BD-066 | MJCF import with a loss report; URDF and MJCF export with the reverse loss report | BD-062, BD-065 | GATE-SKEL-01 |
| BD-067 | Oracle capture scripts; fixtures for reference robots with pin and date | BD-039, BD-066 | Fixtures are on disk with their pins; the regeneration-from-candidate path does not exist |
| BD-068 | INT-FSIM-09: admission of fs-phs interconnection, fs-tribo friction-law selection and fs-matdb material data |
BD-007 | Power across an interconnection sums to zero to 10⁻¹² relative; a missing material pair is a refusal |
| BD-069 | Actuator, battery and transmission cards: the .fcard schema, per-field provenance, the generic catalog; actuator.list, actuator.show, actuator.check |
BD-005, BD-068 | A card without provenance is refused; every card in the catalog passes actuator.check |
| BD-070 | Actuator levels L0 and L1 on the referee | BD-061, BD-069 | L1 rows of GATE-SINEW-01 |
| BD-071 | Actuator level L2: winding current, the thermal network, the battery | BD-070 | Remaining rows of GATE-SINEW-01 |
| BD-072 | Winding temperature with temperature-dependent resistance, and thermal runaway (actuator.thermal) |
BD-071 | GATE-SINEW-05: the worked card's 20 A point is admitted by the constant-resistance check and refused by the corrected one |
| BD-073 | The voltage limit and field weakening (actuator.envelope) |
BD-071 | GATE-SINEW-06 |
| BD-074 | Transmissions: gear, belt, screw, linkage, cable and coupling matrices with loss laws | BD-070 | GATE-SINEW-08: every loss and entropy production is nonnegative over 10⁶ operating points; the single-multiplier gear fixture refuses |
| BD-075 | The power bus and the battery, with brownout events (actuator.bus) |
BD-071 | GATE-SINEW-07 |
| BD-076 | Port energy-balance check on the referee | BD-070 | GATE-SINEW-02 on the referee; a planted unaccounted loss is caught |
| BD-077 | module.substitute and the invalidation contract of C-12 |
BD-060, BD-063, BD-075 | GATE-SKEL-06; KILL-SKEL-SUBST decided |
| BD-078 | The clock contract: rational periods, phase accumulators, the seven instants and the boundary ordering rule (sense.schedule) |
BD-005 | CPU rows of GATE-SENS-04: the 400/30 schedule exactly and zero drift over 10⁹ ticks; an every-thirteenth-step schedule, which runs a 30 Hz policy at 30.77 Hz, is caught |
| BD-079 | frob-contact: collision primitives; contact sets from fs-query; INT-FSIM-08 |
BD-061 | GATE-TRAC-02 |
| BD-080 | The referee step: FrankenSim's contact step on generated contact sets; compliant feet | BD-070, BD-079 | Stand and drop tests pass; a contact set above the capacity returns the typed refusal, never a truncated solve |
| BD-081 | The transactional referee step: the restore set and the commit fence with commit_epoch |
BD-080 | Zero uncommitted reads observed in 10⁵ injected faults (row of GATE-KIN-04) |
| BD-082 | Event location on rational base intervals, with coupled impulses per island | BD-078, BD-081 | Impact time within 10⁻⁹ s and tied sliders exact to 10⁻¹² N·s (rows of GATE-KIN-04); simultaneous impacts are solved together and none is refused for simultaneity |
| BD-083 | The retry ladder that changes numerical parameters only, and the refinement law for random inputs | BD-082 | GATE-KIN-04 on the referee: forced-retry digests equal, refinement statistics inside 3σ at 10⁶ draws, the redraw mutation caught |
| BD-084 | Joint-level stiction, backlash and hard stops as rows in the referee solve | BD-070, BD-082 | GATE-SINEW-04 on the referee; GATE-SINEW-09; backlash modelled as a torque dead zone fails the closure-speed case |
| BD-085 | The contact known-answer battery on the referee | BD-082 | Referee rows of GATE-TRAC-01, with the list of rows FrankenSim's solve can express recorded beside the gate |
| BD-086 | Thin-barrier and sill fixtures under the transactional step | BD-082 | Referee rows of GATE-TRAC-06: zero missed hits in 10⁶ thin-barrier crossings; the endpoint-only mutation is caught |
| BD-087 | The free-body variational step as an oracle S | BD-011 | Free-flight momentum is conserved to 10⁻¹² relative over 10⁶ steps; a right-trivialized differential in the solve fails the four-step test |
| BD-088 | The dynamics known-answer battery | BD-080, BD-087 | GATE-KIN-01 |
| BD-089 | Contact-free dynamics parity against the pinned oracle | BD-067, BD-080 | GATE-KIN-02 |
| BD-090 | frob-chronicle: the ledger schema, .frun episodes, telemetry levels T0 to T2 with streams and channel kinds |
BD-009, BD-080 | Round-trip tests pass; a chunk with one changed byte fails its digest |
| BD-091 | The chunk protocol on the CPU: leases, ranges, the committed frontier | BD-090 | CPU rows of GATE-CHRON-04 |
| BD-092 | The energy ledger on the referee, with stored heat, separate braking modes and the first offending event | BD-071, BD-076, BD-090 | GATE-CHRON-03 on the referee; a damped pendulum's ledger matches the hand calculation |
| BD-093 | Witness migration in the transactional step | BD-035, BD-082, BD-092 | INT-FSIM-07 in full: the flat-to-edge-to-top transition completes with the energy ledger closed to its stated residual |
| BD-094 | Failure taxonomy with outcome kinds, first-cause ordering and budgeted summaries (telemetry.summary, telemetry.failures, telemetry.energy, telemetry.query) |
BD-090 | A fixture per failure class fires its monitor; a numerical fault is never counted as a physical failure or dropped from a denominator |
| BD-095 | The artifact graph (evidence.trace) and the per-bead log frob.beadlog/1 |
BD-004, BD-090 | GATE-CHRON-10 |
| BD-096 | Simulation testing of the ledger and the submit path under asupersync's lab runtime | BD-091 | INT-ASUP-02; CPU part of GATE-CHRON-11 |
| BD-097 | artifact.read, artifact.list, artifact.export, run.show, run.list |
BD-022, BD-090 | A byte-range read returns bytes whose digest matches the record; a traversal path is refused |
| BD-098 | Packet queues and delivered observations, with the queues inside every checkpoint | BD-078, BD-081, BD-090 | Referee rows of GATE-SENS-05: restore at the three adversarial instants gives byte-equal delivered observations |
| BD-099 | Proprioception on the referee: IMU with lever arm, encoders, sensor cards (sense.profile) |
BD-078, BD-080 | The three IMU cases and the turntable case of GATE-SENS-01 on the referee |
| BD-100 | A-02 mass roll-up and A-08 static stability | BD-050, BD-062 | Known answers; a planted top-heavy design is flagged; a point-foot biped is reported, not refused |
| BD-101 | A-01 mobility | BD-046, BD-061 | Sarrus 1, Bennett 1, planar four-bar 1 |
| BD-102 | A-03 symmetry: Γ_mech and Γ_obs with breakers and near-symmetry repairs (analyze.symmetry) |
BD-048, BD-061 | A symmetric quadruped with one forward lidar reports C₂ × C₂, C₂ and the lidar mount as breaker; a planted 0.4% asymmetry is found with its repair |
| BD-103 | A-10 co-design closure and A-11 actuator envelope with the temperature-dependent steady state | BD-052, BD-072, BD-073, BD-075 | A planted undersized actuator is found; a mass spiral that does not close is reported infeasible |
| BD-104 | A-13 self-collision and clearance | BD-079 | A planted limb interference is found |
| BD-105 | A-05 workspace, A-06 singularities, and the derived leg IK kernel; INT-FSYM-02 | BD-019, BD-061 | A 3R leg has four solutions and the singular locus matches the closed form; INT-FSYM-02 |
| BD-106 | A-07 growth vector and maneuverability | BD-061 | The growth vectors of C-07; a mecanum base with parallel rollers reports (2, 3) where (3) is required |
| BD-107 | A-12 modes with symmetry block-diagonalization | BD-102 | Modes of a symmetric two-mass model |
| BD-108 | A-20 energy-budget feasibility, A-21 deadline and latency closure, A-22 sampled-loop stability, A-23 shared-bus schedule | BD-075, BD-078, BD-103 | GATE-ATEL-05 rows for A-20 to A-23; the additive peak rule, which falsely prunes the two-finger bus, is caught |
| BD-109 | The first archetypes: quad-mammal, humanoid, diff-drive, mecanum (design.templates) |
BD-062, BD-064, BD-074, BD-075 | Each compiles and passes its lints; the humanoid's mass lies within 15% of the mass on file for the G1 (row of GATE-SKEL-07) |
| BD-110 | design.check stages 1 to 6: aggregation, ranked repairs as typed edits, per-stage timing |
BD-060, BD-100, BD-101, BD-102, BD-103, BD-104, BD-105, BD-106, BD-109 | GATE-ATEL-02 for the included analyses; GATE-SKEL-04 for stages 1 to 6 |
| BD-111 | The memo graph in front of analyses, with shadow recompute; INT-FSIM-16 | BD-090, BD-110 | Analysis part of GATE-ATEL-12: a shadow mismatch stops serving within one hit; INT-FSIM-16 |
| BD-112 | explain.run and explain.design |
BD-094, BD-110 | The explanation of a planted knee-thermal failure names the first cause and cites the telemetry channel that shows it |
| BD-113 | Lineage basics: the lineage graph over patches, design.diff, design.blame |
BD-059, BD-090 | Blame on a three-edit lineage names the edit that changed a chosen field |
| BD-114 | The invariant filter (control.estimate) |
BD-045 | GATE-REFLEX-03 on a synthetic IMU; the overconfident flag fires on a planted bias |
| BD-115 | The small dense cone-program solver, with end states and dual certificates | BD-050 | KKT residuals; agreement with a reference optimizer on 10³ programs; a planted infeasible program returns a certificate that checks exactly |
| BD-116 | Legged baseline controller | BD-080, BD-105, BD-115 | A quadruped stands and walks 5 m on the referee |
| BD-117 | Wheeled baseline controller | BD-080, BD-106 | Differential and mecanum archetypes traverse 5 m; the wheel loops saturate at the card's current limit |
| BD-118 | control.synth with three-outcome reporting, and control.show |
BD-109, BD-116, BD-117 | GATE-REFLEX-01 on the referee and the standing rows of GATE-SKEL-03, for the first archetypes |
| BD-119 | The causal-policy test (sense.causal-test) |
BD-098, BD-118 | Referee rows of GATE-SENS-12: every baseline controller passes and each of the five planted leaks fails |
| BD-120 | A-17 observability: the linearized Gramian modulo gauge on the CPU (sense.observability) |
BD-099, BD-114 | Linearized rows of GATE-SENS-08: the corridor case and the four-dimensional gauge; two identical aisles are reported ambiguous despite full local rank |
| BD-121 | frob-spec: the requirement language core, with unit-normalized predicates, temporal operators and three evaluators |
BD-005, BD-078 | Monitor rows of GATE-ARENA-03: the three evaluators agree bit for bit on 10⁶ random traces per operator |
| BD-122 | The task file .ftask: terms, requirements, randomization; task.new, task.show, task.list, task.check, task.verdict |
BD-121 | Refusal rows of GATE-ARENA-03: each refusal 520 to 528 is triggered by its planted task file |
| BD-123 | Fixture 1, fixture:cart-sill-dock: bodies, motor, sill, the analytic layer and the creep rigs (task.fixture) |
BD-075, BD-083, BD-084, BD-086, BD-092, BD-122 | GATE-ARENA-04 on the referee: both negative controls are caught |
| BD-124 | The two study types on the CPU: the anytime-valid e-process and the fixed-n exact study with its reachability pre-analysis (study.plan, study.submit, study.status, eval.preanalyze, eval.compare); INT-FSIM-14 |
BD-090, BD-122 | GATE-ARENA-05; GATE-ATEL-06; INT-FSIM-14; a study that declares both types is refused |
| BD-125 | Task families of M1: stand and recover, threshold delivery, timed docking, each with a requirement, labelled traces and a reference scorecard (eval.run, eval.scorecard) |
BD-118, BD-123, BD-124 | Each task is reproducible on the referee from its TaskId, ModelId and seed; a changed seed changes the episode digest |
| BD-126 | .fmission: the mission schema and its admission (mission.new, mission.check), with the quantifier order echoed |
BD-121 | An empty or inconsistent domain is refused; a query written ∀w ∃u where ∃u ∀(w, e) is meant is echoed in the order written and fails the quantifier-order fixture |
| BD-127 | Admission of the second linear-program solver (fsci-opt linprog) and of the airlock entries fs-ivl and fs-sos for mission work |
BD-007 | The two solvers agree on the 51 docking programs of the pilot; a planted infeasible program is reported infeasible by both with a dual that checks |
| BD-128 | frob-mission core: inner and outer design sets, cells, polarity, the proof rules on finite and polyhedral fragments, plain proof objects |
BD-052, BD-115, BD-126, BD-127 | On the quantifier-order fixture the inner set lies inside the exact set and the outer set contains it; an answer formed by intersecting per-world answers is rejected |
| BD-129 | The docking family: the finite game over causal histories with one velocity packet, and its scenario-tree comparator | BD-041, BD-098, BD-128 | GATE-AUGUR-03 |
| BD-130 | The stance family: body–load feasibility with vertex witnesses and dual exclusions, in lifted and projected form | BD-042, BD-128 | GATE-AUGUR-02 |
| BD-131 | The pusher battery: per-build and shared queries on one plant | BD-043, BD-128 | GATE-AUGUR-04 |
| BD-132 | frob-cert checkers for the mission proof kinds (lp-primal, lp-farkas, finite-game, alias-pair, partition, interval-box, trace-witness) |
BD-027 | GATE-LEMMA-03 |
| BD-133 | Mission bundles: the writer in frob-lemma for inner cells and exclusions; prove.bundle, prove.verify, prove.list; frob-verbs runs the checker before an answer returns |
BD-129, BD-130, BD-131, BD-132 | GATE-AUGUR-05; GATE-LEMMA-04: one accepted false certificate fails the gate |
| BD-134 | The late-packet alias witness for the docking mission (sense.alias on enumerated worlds) |
BD-119, BD-129 | The late-packet docking witness of GATE-SENS-09 is found and passes the checker; a pair of worlds with different transcripts is not reported as an alias |
| BD-135 | mission.synthesize, mission.refute, mission.distinguish, mission.show, with budget stops |
BD-133, BD-134 | A budget stop returns the certified cells and the unresolved remainder, each cell complete in itself; no unresolved cell is printed as a verdict |
| BD-136 | The mission mutation corpus and the checker-independence campaign | BD-135 | GATE-AUGUR-01; GATE-AUGUR-06: zero false accepts over at least 200 mutated witnesses per proof kind |
| BD-137 | The M1 verbs with schemas, examples and refusal lists | BD-022, BD-024, BD-057, BD-059, BD-066, BD-077, BD-097, BD-107, BD-108, BD-110, BD-112, BD-113, BD-118, BD-120, BD-125, BD-135 | GATE-TETHER-02 for the M1 verbs |
| BD-138 | MCP tools generated for the M1 verbs in task clusters of at most seven, with session.open, session.show, session.focus, session.close |
BD-023, BD-137 | The parity diff is empty and the served tools/list equals the registry under the name map; after session.focus the list holds at most seven tools plus the base three |
| BD-139 | The reality: line on every report, and its negative battery |
BD-137 | GATE-GROUND-01 |
| BD-140 | The first mission slice driven by a fresh agent through the CLI and MCP | BD-136, BD-138 | GATE-AUGUR-07 |
| BD-141 | The format registry rows and round trips for the formats that exist at M1 (.fbot, .fmodule, .fcard, .ftask, .fmission, .frun, .frobcert) |
BD-004, BD-057, BD-060, BD-069, BD-090, BD-122, BD-126, BD-133 | GATE-WS-02 for these formats; a second parser for a registered extension fails check-contracts |
| BD-142 | Parity baseline completed: incumbents on this Mac (CPU MuJoCo at 1, 24 and 36 threads; an incumbent with a Metal path) and native settings on trj |
BD-040 | GATE-SPARK-21 |
| BD-143 | The incumbent design-loop phase ledger on trj: one agent-driven round timed by phase, cold and warm separated, with the ceilings of §2 recomputed from the measured shares |
BD-040 | The ledger is on record under the disclosure block before any ratio against an incumbent is written; a repeat of the round reproduces each phase's share inside its stated interval |
| BD-144 | Phylum pilot with no GPU code: padding overhead and bucket count of the first archetypes and of 1,000 generated designs under the bucket set | BD-109 | The pilot's numbers and its falsifier outcome are filed; the padding known answers 1.32, 1.58 and 1.76 for p = 1, 2, 3 reproduce |
| BD-145 | Pre-registration of the rank-agreement experiment: design set, strata, the τ thresholds 0.7 and 0.5 fixed before data, and the compute request under OPEN-SPARK-2 | BD-039, BD-124 | The registration is committed before any paired training runs; a threshold edited after the first result is refused by the study record |
| BD-146 | frob-conformance for M1: known answers against pinned oracles, the counterexample catalogue seeds, the smoke and fixtures batteries |
BD-025, BD-067, BD-088, BD-089, BD-123 | GATE-GAUNT-01 for M1: every M1 gate has a registered negative control that it catches |
| BD-147 | M1 exit review by a fresh-context session that did not implement the work; the schedule gate (BET-12, §40.5) | BD-044, BD-049, BD-053, BD-085, BD-093, BD-095, BD-096, BD-111, BD-139, BD-140, BD-141, BD-142, BD-143, BD-144, BD-145, BD-146 | Every gate of M1 has a recorded value and a caught negative control; NS-01, NS-07 and NS-22 are demonstrated; the schedule gate is evaluated; GATE-TENFOLD-02 and -09 are recorded |
45.3 M2: batch, backends, families
M2 puts the batched step on batch-cpu, CUDA and Metal and decides by measurement the four questions the architecture
leaves open: whether the derivation toolchain carries the kernel arithmetic, whether the contact law is adequate,
whether Metal is a rollout tier, and whether mixed cohorts are the engine. The strict profile lands here (BD-161)
because it runs on the batched kernels; the strict rows of the M1 gates close with it.
| Bead | Title | Depends on | Done when |
|---|---|---|---|
| BD-148 | Packed lowering of RobotModel: depth levels, path tables, capacities, ShapeClassId |
BD-018, BD-061 | The layout digest is stable across platforms |
| BD-149 | Derive and emit K-fk-level and K-twist-level |
BD-019, BD-148 | Parity with fs-mbd forward kinematics |
| BD-150 | Derive and emit K-crba-level and K-rnea-level |
BD-149 | Rows of GATE-KIN-03 |
| BD-151 | K-act-l1, K-act-l2, K-passive, and the shared-bus reduction K-act-bus |
BD-071, BD-075, BD-148 | GATE-SINEW-03 |
| BD-152 | Utility kernels: K-scan, K-sort, K-reduce, K-seg-reduce, K-compact |
BD-014 | Bitwise equal across worker counts; padding a reduction with −0.0 as the neutral element is caught |
| BD-153 | K-jac-rows, K-cone-setup, K-cone-eval for CL-1 |
BD-050, BD-150 | KKT and projection tests |
| BD-154 | The four-dimensional contact cone (normal, two tangential, spin) in the Cone trait and the cone kernels |
BD-153 | Cone rows of GATE-TRAC-04: coupled and diagonal forces within 0.5% of μ·N/√2 and μ·N; the pyramid and independent-row mutations fail |
| BD-155 | K-joint-rows: stiction, backlash and hard stops on the batched tiers |
BD-084, BD-153 | Joint rows of GATE-TRAC-04; GATE-SINEW-04 on batched tiers within the stated regularization; KILL-SINEW-ROWS decided |
| BD-156 | K-scale-diag, K-hess, batched dense K-chol, exact K-linesearch, K-refine |
BD-154 | Convergence on the battery with the gradient-norm certificate recorded; GATE-TRAC-10 |
| BD-157 | Articulated K-cay-step, K-normalize, K-anchor |
BD-149 | Group-membership test over 10⁶ steps |
| BD-158 | K-geom-pose, K-np-prim, K-bp-sort, K-bp-pairs: poses of primitives, primitive pairs, the deterministic broad phase |
BD-079, BD-148, BD-152 | Primitive pair distances match the CPU primitives of GATE-TRAC-02 on its 10⁶ pairs, inside the class; the broad-phase pair order is identical across worker counts |
| BD-159 | The batched step on batch-cpu in f64 and f32, with lockstep masks and capacity flags |
BD-151, BD-152, BD-155, BD-156, BD-157, BD-158 | A quadruped drops, stands and walks under the baseline controller; GATE-KIN-03; a forced contact overflow is flagged Degraded, never dropped silently |
| BD-160 | The tile program on fs-exec with fixed-slot reductions |
BD-159 | Bitwise equal across worker counts |
| BD-161 | The strict profile of batch-cpu: the transactional, event-located step in f64 on our own kernels |
BD-083, BD-093, BD-159 | The strict rows of GATE-KIN-04, GATE-TRAC-01 and GATE-TRAC-06; the rate is printed with every strict result |
| BD-162 | frob-scene: the .fscene scene-pack format, bricks, interpolation bounds, truncated fields with a stated range |
BD-005 | Schema and round trip; a field value outside its stated range is refused, not clipped |
| BD-163 | The scene compiler through the airlock, with analytic overlays (scene.compile, scene.show, scene.list) |
BD-007, BD-162 | GATE-HAB-01 |
| BD-164 | The brick pool with one dense directory per scene variant | BD-163 | GATE-HAB-13; KILL-POOL decided |
| BD-165 | Terrain generators with a difficulty parameter (scene.gen) |
BD-163 | The same seed gives the same SceneId on Linux and macOS |
| BD-166 | K-np-sdf with overlays and the pooled directory; K-np-thin |
BD-158, BD-164 | The sphere-against-field known answer; a thin barrier between two clear endpoint poses is detected |
| BD-167 | Rolling and torsional rows; interface cards by material pair and condition (contact.laws, contact.probe) |
BD-068, BD-154 | Incline, rolling and mecanum known answers; a missing material pair is refused |
| BD-168 | The contact battery on batched tiers; the tunneling audit; the capacity audit (contact.audit, contact.capacity) |
BD-085, BD-159, BD-161, BD-166, BD-167 | GATE-TRAC-01 and GATE-TRAC-06 on batched tiers; GATE-TRAC-03; a verdict shaped by capacity is labelled capacity-biased |
| BD-169 | Per-world parameter variants (level P-A): model, scene and task slots with a parameter row | BD-159 | batch-cpu rows of GATE-KIN-06: 256 parameter variants equal 256 homogeneous runs bit for bit |
| BD-170 | Model variants inside padded capacities (level P-B): one model table per slot, masks, K-variant-gather |
BD-169 | batch-cpu rows of GATE-PHYLUM-02; a padded link changes no digest of a real link |
| BD-171 | Size buckets and phylum.plan |
BD-144, BD-170 | Bucket plans reproduce the padding known answers; a population that needs more than eight buckets is reported against KILL-BUCKET |
| BD-172 | CUDA backend: buffers, the step plan (frob.stepplan/1), launch-graph capture, stream-ordered pools, receipts |
BD-015, BD-159 | The full step runs on one RTX 4090; GATE-SPARK-12 |
| BD-173 | The device arena, leases and the binary kernel cache (spark.cache, spark.precompile) |
BD-172 | GATE-SPARK-11 |
| BD-174 | Metal backend: packed arguments, batch chains, snapshot blits, receipts | BD-016, BD-028, BD-159 | The full step runs on this Mac |
| BD-175 | Device faults and cancellation | BD-172, BD-174 | GATE-SPARK-06 |
| BD-176 | spark.check and the divergence ledger |
BD-017, BD-020, BD-172, BD-174 | GATE-SPARK-02; KILL-D1 decided per device family |
| BD-177 | The decision-level equivalence test under class D3 | BD-176 | GATE-SPARK-16: a planted bias of one decision in fifty fails |
| BD-178 | The placement planner with requested-versus-actual receipts per stage, and strict backends (spark.place, frob.placement/1) |
BD-172, BD-174 | GATE-SPARK-09 |
| BD-179 | Anchored positions (cell side 8 m, offset in [−4, 4) m), the precision battery and the conditioning certificate | BD-156, BD-172, BD-174 | GATE-SPARK-05; GATE-SPARK-18; the uncentred [0, 8) shift fails the battery |
| BD-180 | Randomness by address: K-x-philox and addressed draws |
BD-152 | Draws depend on address alone; an implementation that draws sequentially is caught |
| BD-181 | The batch-composition invariance test: co-tenancy, slot permutation, bucket capacity, shards | BD-170, BD-172, BD-174, BD-180 | GATE-SPARK-15; GATE-KIN-05 |
| BD-182 | Guarded predicates on devices over the contact battery | BD-053, BD-168, BD-172, BD-174 | GATE-MARROW-05; KILL-MARROW-GUARD decided |
| BD-183 | Variants on devices: parameter variants, topology variants on one captured graph, a mixed batch of three body plans, admission of a variant into a free slot | BD-170, BD-171, BD-172, BD-174 | GATE-SPARK-10; device rows of GATE-KIN-06 and GATE-PHYLUM-02 |
| BD-184 | Admission and edit-to-first-step latency on the warm, cool and cold paths (phylum.sweep) |
BD-040, BD-173, BD-183 | GATE-PHYLUM-04 |
| BD-185 | The control arm of the head-to-head: nine padded per-family templates with lockable joints and per-design parameter tables | BD-169 | Each template family of §14 runs as a homogeneous environment; the share of the mutation corpus the arm can express is recorded |
| BD-186 | The mixed-batch head-to-head experiment with arms A, B, C and D, as a fixed-n study | BD-039, BD-124, BD-181, BD-183, BD-184, BD-185 | GATE-PHYLUM-03 published with all four arms; KILL-PHYLUM and KILL-BUCKET decided by the pre-declared outcomes |
| BD-187 | Ray kernels; height scan, depth, lidar; proprioception with noise on batched tiers | BD-099, BD-166, BD-172, BD-174 | GATE-SENS-01; GATE-SENS-02 |
| BD-188 | Camera timing: exposure integration, rolling shutter and lidar beam instants | BD-078, BD-187 | GATE-SENS-06; KILL-EXPOSURE decided |
| BD-189 | The clock contract and checkpointed packet queues on every tier | BD-078, BD-098, BD-172, BD-174 | GATE-SENS-04 and GATE-SENS-05 on every tier; KILL-SCHED decided |
| BD-190 | The docking fixture in exact arithmetic on every backend | BD-030, BD-129, BD-189 | GATE-SENS-13 |
| BD-191 | Stills and pixel inspection (telemetry.stills, telemetry.inspect-pixel, telemetry.export-html) |
BD-187 | A pixel maps to the right link in fixtures |
| BD-192 | VecEnv with the corrected semantics E-1 to E-9: explicit reset, the preserved final observation, termination against truncation, typed spaces, access classes, snapshots, and masked automatic reset as a labeled mode |
BD-098, BD-159 | GATE-CORTEX-06 |
| BD-193 | Device-resident tensor views with the stride converter and ownership epochs | BD-036, BD-172, BD-174, BD-192 | GATE-CORTEX-09 |
| BD-194 | Declarative task specifications with requirement terms, time-aware rewards, physical discounting and the likelihood of the applied action | BD-122, BD-192 | The 500 against 1,000 reward fixture is invariant under rate terms; the 2.000 and 1.995 discount fixture holds across control rates |
| BD-195 | The settled-pose reset cache | BD-192 | GATE-ARENA-08 |
| BD-196 | On-device networks and optimizer (K-gemm, K-act-fn, K-adam); gradient parity with FrankenTorch |
BD-172, BD-174 | GATE-CORTEX-02; KILL-LEARNKERN decided |
| BD-197 | PPO under rules P-1 to P-11 | BD-034, BD-194, BD-196 | GATE-CORTEX-07: the battery passes, and three planted defects that reproduce the sibling's errors each fail it |
| BD-198 | PPO training of the reference quadruped's flat velocity task, with negative controls; train.start, train.status, train.stop, train.export |
BD-193, BD-195, BD-197 | GATE-CORTEX-01 on batch-cpu and on each GPU backend |
| BD-199 | Sharding across both RTX 4090, and multi-device PPO under the global normalization rule | BD-198 | GATE-CORTEX-08; GATE-SPARK-20; KILL-SHARD decided |
| BD-200 | Randomization from cards, drawn by address | BD-069, BD-180, BD-192 | A card field with no interval refuses randomization; two runs at one address draw the same value in any batch |
| BD-201 | Task families of M2: velocity tracking and terrain traversal, with reference-robot scorecards | BD-165, BD-194, BD-200 | GATE-ARENA-01 |
| BD-202 | Fixture 2, fixture:quad-split-grip |
BD-167, BD-201 | GATE-ARENA-06 |
| BD-203 | In-kernel digests (K-x-digest), per-stage digests, snapshots at the fence (K-commit, K-snapshot), replay (sim.replay) |
BD-090, BD-159, BD-172, BD-174 | GATE-CHRON-01 |
| BD-204 | Teleport with step and stage localization (sim.replay --tier) |
BD-176, BD-203 | GATE-CHRON-02 |
| BD-205 | Forks from snapshots by indexed copy, and their classification into the five classes of §27.4 (run.fork) |
BD-203 | GATE-CHRON-05; GATE-AUTOPSY-01; GATE-AUTOPSY-02 |
| BD-206 | The first-divergence search over the digest chain, in exact and tolerance modes (telemetry.divergence) |
BD-203 | GATE-CHRON-06; GATE-AUTOPSY-07 |
| BD-207 | Telemetry on devices: the reservoir by address, deterministic integer histograms (K-x-hist, telemetry.histogram), the cost of T0 to T2 |
BD-180, BD-203 | GATE-CHRON-07; GATE-CHRON-13 |
| BD-208 | The energy ledger on batched tiers (K-ledger-step) and the audit for energy created by the simulator (fidelity.energy) |
BD-092, BD-159, BD-172, BD-174 | Single-precision rows of GATE-CHRON-03 and GATE-SINEW-02; GATE-CHRON-08; GATE-FID-06 |
| BD-209 | Retention and collection with tombstones (store.status, store.collect) |
BD-095 | GATE-CHRON-12 |
| BD-210 | The crash-consistent job protocol on devices: chunk publish, leases, cancel, restart; job.list, job.status, job.wait, job.find, job.cancel |
BD-091, BD-096, BD-172, BD-174 | Device rows of GATE-CHRON-04 and GATE-CHRON-11; GATE-TETHER-08 |
| BD-211 | Atomic idempotency binding, pagination pinned to a committed frontier, integers above 2⁵³ as strings | BD-059, BD-210 | GATE-TETHER-05; GATE-TETHER-06; GATE-TETHER-07 |
| BD-212 | The standard battery, frozen; the fidelity ledger with its frozen envelopes (fidelity.ledger) |
BD-123, BD-168, BD-202, BD-208 | GATE-FID-01, with the one permitted re-baseline written down; GATE-KIN-07; GATE-ARENA-04 on the batch tiers; KILL-CONTACT decided |
| BD-213 | The referee's own coverage report per robot class (fidelity.coverage) |
BD-161, BD-212 | GATE-FID-03 |
| BD-214 | The sampled background referee (fidelity.shadow): address-hashed sampling, snapshots, one-step defects, the coverage figure on every receipt |
BD-161, BD-203, BD-212 | GATE-FID-07 at the M2 exit: the share of device world-seconds shadowed is reported with a throughput loss of at most 5% (row 17 of §36.3); a run with no sampler prints a share of zero |
| BD-215 | The noninterference test, and the causal-policy test on every tier | BD-119, BD-191, BD-203, BD-207 | GATE-SENS-03; GATE-SENS-12 |
| BD-216 | The performance harness: unit ordering, the paired lower bound, the disclosure block | BD-025, BD-029 | GATE-SPARK-19 |
| BD-217 | Profile, optimize one lever at a time, measure, disclose: the throughput parity rows | BD-142, BD-160, BD-183, BD-198, BD-216 | GATE-SPARK-03 and GATE-SPARK-04 recorded as measured, pass or fail; KILL-PARITY and KILL-METAL decided |
| BD-218 | Training-time parity on one RTX 4090 | BD-217 | GATE-CORTEX-05 |
| BD-219 | The sim.estimate cost and memory model |
BD-217 | GATE-SPARK-22 |
| BD-220 | Memoized episodes under class D2 on one fingerprint; INT-FSQL-02 | BD-111, BD-203 | Episode part of GATE-ATEL-12; INT-FSQL-02; an episode recorded on another fingerprint is not served |
| BD-221 | The derivation toolchain measured against KILL-KIR; INT-FJAX-01 only if the profile asks for rewrite rules | BD-150, BD-156, BD-217 | The share of kernel arithmetic the toolchain expresses and emits, and the emitted kernels' speed against BET-01's bound, are recorded; KILL-KIR decided |
| BD-222 | The M2 verbs with schemas, examples and refusal lists | BD-137, BD-173, BD-178, BD-186, BD-188, BD-191, BD-198, BD-204, BD-205, BD-206, BD-209, BD-211, BD-213, BD-214, BD-219 | GATE-TETHER-02 for the M2 verbs |
| BD-223 | frob-conformance for M2: the standard battery wiring, metamorphic relations, chaos tests on devices |
BD-146, BD-175, BD-179, BD-212, BD-215 | GATE-GAUNT-01 for M2 |
| BD-224 | M2 exit review by a fresh-context session that did not implement the work; kill decisions as ADRs | BD-147, BD-177, BD-182, BD-190, BD-199, BD-218, BD-220, BD-221, BD-222, BD-223 | Every gate of M2 has a recorded value and a caught negative control; the kill decisions for the kernel toolchain, contact, Metal and mixed batches are recorded as ADRs |
45.4 M3: places, tasks, adversaries, qualification
M3 adds the seven interior archetypes, the task families, Nemesis, Autopsy, the qualification lane and the full agent surface, and ends with the partial ten-fold gate on legged and wheeled briefs. The partial gate is GATE-TENFOLD-06 and the tournament is GATE-TENFOLD-07 (§39.18, §40.5); BD-314 to BD-317 cite the gates they close.
| Bead | Title | Depends on | Done when |
|---|---|---|---|
| BD-225 | The interior grammar mechanism and the structural proxies of the warehouse and the commercial kitchen, with doors, ramps, thresholds, stairs, glass and mirror regions | BD-165 | 1,000 seeds per archetype satisfy every dimensional constraint of the grammar; the same seed gives the same SceneId on Linux and macOS |
| BD-226 | Structural proxies of the home, apartment, office, manufacturing plant and retail store | BD-225 | 1,000 seeds per archetype satisfy every constraint; repeated modules land on the coarse lattice and their bricks are stored once |
| BD-227 | Hazard lists: registries/hazards/<archetype>.toml with dimension ranges, mechanisms, provoked failures and provenance (scene.hazards) |
BD-226 | A pack counts the assumed dimensions it used; a report that claims a scene is representative while that count is non-zero is refused (FROB-REF-312) |
| BD-228 | Scene acceptance (scene.accept) |
BD-225 | GATE-HAB-04 |
| BD-229 | Optical and friction properties as separate maps; fixtures and movable objects | BD-225 | GATE-HAB-05 |
| BD-230 | The film-friction law: Habitat's thickness state and Traction's cone row (K-film) |
BD-154, BD-167, BD-229 | GATE-HAB-06; GATE-TRAC-05; KILL-FILM decided |
| BD-231 | Rigid proxies: a rug as a free slab, a cord as a fixed ridge or a free rod, clutter as rigid bodies | BD-225 | The free-slab rug slides in the castor case, where a fixed step would not |
| BD-232 | The mesh path with enclosures and a bounding-volume hierarchy; thin-feature detection | BD-166 | A feature thinner than the brick bound is routed to thin primitives or refused (FROB-REF-320); KILL-MESHGPU decided |
| BD-233 | Clearance complexes .fclear: two-sided cells, path witnesses and component cuts; enclosure tests (contact.clearance); A-18 |
BD-053, BD-132, BD-163, BD-232 | GATE-HAB-10; GATE-TRAC-07; KILL-FCLEAR decided |
| BD-234 | Feasibility tags for generated scenes, from the clearance complex | BD-226, BD-233 | GATE-HAB-02 |
| BD-235 | Train and test hygiene: scene.split, building-level holdouts, mirrored layouts and edited variants |
BD-226 | GATE-HAB-14; GATE-ARENA-02 |
| BD-236 | The world bank (scene.bank): resident scenes under the admission cap, a change of scene at reset |
BD-164, BD-183, BD-226 | GATE-HAB-12; KILL-BANK-BREADTH decided |
| BD-237 | Optical failure modes: mirror, glass, steam, pattern dropout, with a reason on every masked sample | BD-187, BD-229 | GATE-SENS-07 |
| BD-238 | Sensor cards with failure modes and per-field provenance | BD-237 | GATE-SENS-14 |
| BD-239 | The empirical observability Gramian on batched tiers | BD-120, BD-187 | GATE-SENS-08 |
| BD-240 | The alias-witness search over admitted world families (sense.alias) |
BD-134, BD-225 | GATE-SENS-09; KILL-ALIAS decided |
| BD-241 | Γ_obs per robot and task, with the equivariance test (sense.symmetry) |
BD-102, BD-187 | GATE-SENS-10 |
| BD-242 | Sensor calibration as a least-squares pose graph (sense.calibrate) |
BD-187 | GATE-SENS-11 |
| BD-243 | A-09 connection curvature, A-14 sensor coverage, A-16 sensitivity; INT-FSIM-10 | BD-007, BD-106, BD-187 | The connection curvature on the snake crawler has the sign fixed in §13.8, and a planted sign flip of the bracket term is caught; INT-FSIM-10 |
| BD-244 | Preflight stages 7 (place) and 8 (information) | BD-110, BD-233, BD-240, BD-243 | GATE-SKEL-04 for stages 7 and 8; KILL-SKEL-ALIAS decided |
| BD-245 | Contact laws for the remaining archetypes on all tiers: belt, skid, pad, roller-wheel, wheel-rolling |
BD-167 | Skid turning in place costs the scrub work of the belt-law known answer; a no-slip model of the same base is caught |
| BD-246 | The remaining fourteen archetypes | BD-060, BD-102, BD-109, BD-245 | Each compiles and passes stages 1 to 6 with no refusal; GATE-SKEL-07; GATE-MARROW-03 |
| BD-247 | Baseline controllers for every archetype: multi-legged, biped balance, steered, omnidirectional, tracked, hybrid, arm on a base | BD-118, BD-159, BD-246 | GATE-SKEL-03; GATE-REFLEX-01 on referee and batch-cpu |
| BD-248 | The design corpus: about 200 designs with frozen labels, planted defects, planted winners and planted single causes | BD-246 | The hash of the label file is committed before any analysis is tuned; a relabel changes the corpus identity |
| BD-249 | Validation of baseline synthesis on the corpus | BD-110, BD-247, BD-248 | GATE-REFLEX-02; KILL-BASELINE decided |
| BD-250 | Validation of static analysis on the corpus | BD-110, BD-124, BD-248 | GATE-ATEL-01; KILL-STATIC decided |
| BD-251 | Control programs with layer records, infeasibility certificates and fallback events | BD-115, BD-132, BD-247 | GATE-REFLEX-05 |
| BD-252 | The sampling-based predictive controller as a fallback (control.mpc; K-fork, K-cost, K-weight) |
BD-205, BD-247 | The controlled world's digest does not change with the fork count; FROB-REF-817 fires on a planted acceptance request |
| BD-253 | Task families of M3: interior navigation, payload transport, low-friction crossing, tight-space maneuvering | BD-201, BD-230, BD-231, BD-234, BD-247 | GATE-ARENA-01 for these families, with reference-robot scorecards on the warehouse and kitchen proxies |
| BD-254 | Metrics, scorecard accounting and the batteries standard, full, hard, covering |
BD-253 | GATE-ARENA-07 |
| BD-255 | Requirement verdicts on batched tiers: streaming past-time monitors, task.verdict, task.settle, frob.verdict/1 |
BD-194, BD-253 | GATE-CORTEX-10 |
| BD-256 | The requirement-writing test with a fresh agent | BD-138, BD-255 | GATE-ARENA-09 |
| BD-257 | The requirement reward-term pilot under three arms | BD-198, BD-255 | KILL-SPEC-REWARD decided from five seeds per arm |
| BD-258 | Capabilities, namespaces and many agents: scopes, session budgets, the path jail | BD-210, BD-211 | GATE-SAFE-10; a session without the scope receives the refusal and no partial data |
| BD-259 | The blinded qualification lane: sealed world clusters, pre-committed requests, receipts, the error budget α_i = α / [i·(i+1)] (eval.qualify, eval.ledger) |
BD-124, BD-235, BD-255 | A planted true gain of the declared size is promoted within 10 requests in at least 80% of campaigns; the same adversary against reused clusters at a constant level is caught |
| BD-260 | The 500-retry gate on no-signal worlds | BD-259 | GATE-QUAL-01 |
| BD-261 | The confirmation firewall: capability scopes qual:admin and qual:run, the sealed-field audit |
BD-258, BD-259 | GATE-QUAL-02; GATE-SAFE-03 |
| BD-262 | Anytime-valid paired comparison on devices (eval.compare, study.compare, explain.compare) |
BD-124, BD-181, BD-192 | Type-I error at or below α under optional stopping over 10⁴ null comparisons (row of GATE-ATEL-04); a D4 arm in a paired comparison is refused |
| BD-263 | The trust ladder and the promotion rule with the DC-01 table (eval.promote) |
BD-212, BD-262 | GATE-FID-02: a planted tier-sensitive policy is caught (NS-09) |
| BD-264 | The tier-correction ledger: control variate and doubly robust correction | BD-263 | GATE-CHRON-09; GATE-FID-08; KILL-DR decided |
| BD-265 | Rank agreement between tiers on the 40-design set (eval.rank-agreement on a tier pair) |
BD-248, BD-263 | GATE-FID-04; KILL-RANK decided for tier pairs |
| BD-266 | The model-form rank check (fidelity.modelform) |
BD-208, BD-263 | GATE-FID-05; GATE-CORTEX-15 |
| BD-267 | Exploitation detectors (eval.detect) |
BD-208, BD-263 | GATE-CORTEX-04 |
| BD-268 | The background referee at its gate | BD-214, BD-264 | GATE-FID-07 repeated with the tier-correction ledger; KILL-SHADOW decided |
| BD-269 | Determinism-class licences and the labeled D4 training profile | BD-177, BD-198, BD-262 | GATE-SPARK-17; GATE-SAFE-09 |
| BD-270 | The Nemesis search space and the legality set (frob.legality/1), with the hazard registries as the scene-edit vocabulary |
BD-227 | 100 of 100 planted illegal edits are refused (row of GATE-NEMESIS-01) |
| BD-271 | The solvability oracle (nemesis.oracle) |
BD-233, BD-252, BD-270 | GATE-NEMESIS-01 |
| BD-272 | The artifact guard | BD-263, BD-270 | GATE-NEMESIS-06 |
| BD-273 | The falsification score and the search (nemesis.search) |
BD-255, BD-271, BD-272 | GATE-NEMESIS-02; KILL-NEMESIS decided |
| BD-274 | Shrinking to a minimal counterexample world .fmcw (nemesis.shrink) |
BD-273 | GATE-NEMESIS-03; KILL-MCW decided |
| BD-275 | The hard-world set (nemesis.hardset, frob.hardset/1) |
BD-254, BD-274 | A hard world offered as a confirmation sample is refused; adopting one into a regression battery changes the battery's identity |
| BD-276 | Rare failures, certification lane: bounded-weight estimation with the defensive mixture (nemesis.bound) |
BD-273 | GATE-NEMESIS-04 |
| BD-277 | Rare failures, exploration lane: splitting | BD-276 | GATE-NEMESIS-05; KILL-RARE decided |
| BD-278 | Scene-set coverage by submodular selection (nemesis.cover) |
BD-226, BD-254 | GATE-NEMESIS-08 |
| BD-279 | Interventions and the placebo fork (autopsy.intervene) |
BD-205 | A placebo fork equals replay on 1,000 worlds; a mid-episode gear change is refused with the right fields |
| BD-280 | Interventional contrasts with flip rates, in double precision (autopsy.attribute) |
BD-248, BD-279 | GATE-AUTOPSY-03; KILL-AUTOPSY decided |
| BD-281 | Coalitions and budgeted Shapley summaries | BD-280 | GATE-AUTOPSY-04 |
| BD-282 | The decision model for attribution, with abstention (DC-06) | BD-280 | GATE-AUTOPSY-05 |
| BD-283 | Design parameters re-run from the episode start (autopsy.rerun) |
BD-072, BD-279 | GATE-AUTOPSY-06 |
| BD-284 | Time-travel debugging as an agent workflow (autopsy.repair, autopsy.show) |
BD-206, BD-281, BD-282, BD-283 | A recorded transcript replays to the same repair; citing an attribution as established is refused (FROB-REF-880) |
| BD-285 | Campaign quotienting: the similarity canonical form, orbit representatives, the mission-observable digest (phylum.quotient) |
BD-049, BD-170, BD-241 | GATE-PHYLUM-01; KILL-QUOTIENT decided |
| BD-286 | The invalidation contract for reuse across designs (phylum.reuse) |
BD-220, BD-285 | GATE-PHYLUM-05 |
| BD-287 | The morphology generator with GeneratorId and DesignSplit (phylum.generate) |
BD-246, BD-285 | GATE-PHYLUM-07 |
| BD-288 | Monotone transport of verdicts, with its falsification harness | BD-135 | GATE-AUGUR-08 |
| BD-289 | The region-certificate pilot of §25.6 on the 12-parameter box | BD-135 | The undecided share of the best arm and the largest share from one monotone bound are on file; KILL-AUGUR-REGION decided before the work package is funded |
| BD-290 | Alias and jaw fixtures; mission.refute on the blind payload task |
BD-135, BD-240 | GATE-AUGUR-10; KILL-AUGUR-ALIAS decided |
| BD-291 | Probe and instrument design (mission.distinguish, scene.probe-request) |
BD-135 | The pilot of GATE-AUGUR-11; KILL-AUGUR-PROBE decided |
| BD-292 | The revalidation engine behind result.revalidate and mission.revalidate: dependency grades 1 and 2, polarity |
BD-135, BD-220, BD-288 | GATE-AUGUR-12; dependency-grade rows of GATE-ATEL-11; KILL-AUGUR-REUSE decided |
| BD-293 | Separation of two designs by a minimized world pair (mission.separate) |
BD-135, BD-202, BD-274 | GATE-AUGUR-13; KILL-AUGUR-SEPARATE decided |
| BD-294 | Checker independence repeated over every proof kind in use at M3 | BD-136, BD-233, BD-251, BD-290 | GATE-AUGUR-06 at M3 |
| BD-295 | The daemon: persistent environments with slot-level episode dispatch | BD-181, BD-183, BD-210 | GATE-TETHER-09; KILL-SLOT decided |
| BD-296 | Size classes, shortest estimated work and preempt-resume, with the DC-09 table | BD-219, BD-295 | GATE-TETHER-10; KILL-PREEMPT decided |
| BD-297 | Estimates and budgets: calibrated intervals per stratum | BD-296 | GATE-TETHER-11 |
| BD-298 | The full MCP surface: seventeen task clusters, the bounded synchronous wait, progress and cancellation, resources, prompts | BD-138, BD-258, BD-295 | GATE-TETHER-12; KILL-MCPTASKS decided |
| BD-299 | The three failure classes on both surfaces | BD-298 | GATE-TETHER-04 |
| BD-300 | The dashboard frob-tui (INT-FTUI-01) and the viewer overlays (INT-F3D-01) |
BD-191, BD-295 | GATE-TETHER-14; INT-FTUI-01; INT-F3D-01; KILL-TUI decided |
| BD-301 | The Gymnasium-compatible adapter bindings/frob-gymnasium |
BD-192, BD-198 | GATE-CORTEX-16; KILL-GYMADAPT decided |
| BD-302 | report.design, report.run, report.campaign, report.mission |
BD-095, BD-135, BD-254, BD-263 | Every number in a report resolves to its evidence through evidence.trace; a model-conditional result printed without its condition is refused |
| BD-303 | The no-authorization flags on every exporting verb | BD-027, BD-222 | GATE-SAFE-01 |
| BD-304 | Imported text as data: the x-frob-untrusted mark through every verb that echoes imported text |
BD-298 | GATE-SAFE-02 |
| BD-305 | Private places and licences: the private mark, licence joins, scene.purge |
BD-209, BD-225 | GATE-SAFE-04; GATE-SAFE-05 |
| BD-306 | Supply-chain checks: one asupersync package per workspace, committed lockfiles, kernel-cache integrity | BD-008, BD-173 | GATE-SAFE-06 |
| BD-307 | Importer fuzz targets and limits | BD-066, BD-163 | GATE-SAFE-07 |
| BD-308 | The claim product at the boundary | BD-222 | GATE-SAFE-08 |
| BD-309 | Decision-core tables DC-01, DC-09 and DC-10 in registries/cores/ (cores.show) |
BD-263, BD-278, BD-296 | Rows of GATE-ATEL-13 for these cores: each table regenerates bit-identically and each fallback is demonstrated by forcing its trigger |
| BD-310 | The rank-agreement and ladder pilots on an incumbent engine or on batch-cpu |
BD-145, BD-248, BD-265 | The pilot record of GATE-CORTEX-12 exists with τ, top-10 recall and intervals per class; pilot rows of GATE-ATEL-07 and GATE-ATEL-08 |
| BD-311 | The published-anchor comparison under the Parity label | BD-139, BD-212 | A report prints reality: published-anchor with its source and issues no band |
| BD-312 | The M3 verbs with schemas, examples and refusal lists | BD-222, BD-228, BD-234, BD-235, BD-236, BD-238, BD-239, BD-242, BD-244, BD-251, BD-259, BD-266, BD-267, BD-269, BD-275, BD-277, BD-284, BD-286, BD-287, BD-291, BD-292, BD-293, BD-297, BD-302 | GATE-TETHER-02 for the M3 verbs |
| BD-313 | robot-docs, the skill file and the two worked sessions; the fresh-agent test |
BD-298, BD-299, BD-312 | GATE-TETHER-01 |
| BD-314 | The partial ten-fold gate, protocol: sealed legged and wheeled briefs, strata, the decision rule with its reachable verdicts, the ceilings, the adjudicating evaluator | BD-124, BD-143, BD-218, BD-260 | GATE-TENFOLD-03, -04, -05, -10, -11: the protocol is committed before either arm runs; a stratum whose computed ceiling is below its claimed ratio is refused |
| BD-315 | The partial ten-fold gate, incumbent arm: the strongest composed rival at pinned versions, warm, driven through its own tools and the adapter | BD-039, BD-301, BD-314 | Restricted mean times to an independently accepted answer are recorded per brief with the phase ledger, cold and warm runs separated |
| BD-316 | The partial ten-fold gate, our arm: fresh agents on the full MCP surface | BD-249, BD-261, BD-273, BD-280, BD-294, BD-302, BD-313, BD-314 | Restricted mean times are recorded per brief with the phase ledger; one false certificate disqualifies the arm (KILL-AUGUR-FALSECERT) |
| BD-317 | The partial ten-fold gate, adjudication and record | BD-315, BD-316 | GATE-TENFOLD-06 and GATE-TENFOLD-13: the ratio and the recovery ratios are recorded whatever they are, under the rule of BET-13; KILL-FAMILYCERT and KILL-AUGUR-TIE decided |
| BD-318 | frob-conformance for M3: the hard and covering batteries, the planted-defect registries of Nemesis and Autopsy, the hostile-input corpora of §37 |
BD-223, BD-275, BD-278, BD-284, BD-304, BD-306, BD-307, BD-308 | GATE-GAUNT-01 for M3 |
| BD-319 | M3 exit review by a fresh-context session that did not implement the work | BD-224, BD-250, BD-256, BD-257, BD-268, BD-289, BD-300, BD-303, BD-305, BD-309, BD-310, BD-311, BD-317, BD-318 | Every gate of M3 has a recorded value and a caught negative control; the partial ten-fold gate is recorded, whatever the ratio |
45.5 M4: amortized control, co-design, mission queries at scale
Most mechanisms of M4 are Frontier. Each of their beads closes with its kill gate decided, and a bead whose pilot has no recorded result is not ready (§45.11).
| Bead | Title | Depends on | Done when |
|---|---|---|---|
| BD-320 | Family policies per morphology class: link tokens, the mapping table (frob.policy/1), pretraining on a GeneratorId with a DesignSplit (train.family) |
BD-183, BD-198, BD-287 | The pilot of §23.22 has run and its falsifier outcome is on file; a design outside the class is declined, not scored |
| BD-321 | The family-policy experiment on held-out parametric designs, with the fine-tuning rungs | BD-320 | GATE-CORTEX-11; KILL-FAMILY decided |
| BD-322 | Inheritance along design edits (train.inherit, policy.apply) |
BD-058, BD-320 | GATE-CORTEX-13; KILL-INHERIT decided |
| BD-323 | Distillation from baseline, specialist and sampling-controller teachers (train.distill) |
BD-198, BD-247, BD-252 | GATE-CORTEX-14; KILL-DISTILL decided |
| BD-324 | Pilots of the other learning algorithms of §23.22 against PPO at equal wall-clock | BD-039, BD-198 | Each pilot's result is on file; KILL-ALTALGO decided per algorithm, and no algorithm is built without a passed pilot |
| BD-325 | Equivariant linear maps by irreducible blocks under Γ_obs | BD-048, BD-241 | GATE-MARROW-04; KILL-MARROW-BLOCKS decided |
| BD-326 | The three-arm equivariance experiment | BD-198, BD-325 | GATE-CORTEX-03; KILL-EQUIV decided |
| BD-327 | Symmetric controllers under stabilizer intersection (control.symmetry) |
BD-241, BD-247 | GATE-REFLEX-07 |
| BD-328 | The rank-agreement experiment on our engine, per morphology class and task family (eval.rank-agreement; the model-form check is fidelity.modelform) |
BD-249, BD-310, BD-321 | GATE-CORTEX-12; GATE-ATEL-07; GATE-REFLEX-04; KILL-RANK decided for rungs |
| BD-329 | The ladder of rungs R0 to R5: the fixed halving table and the calibrated layer with DC-02 and DC-03 | BD-250, BD-263, BD-276, BD-328 | GATE-ATEL-08; KILL-LADDER decided |
| BD-330 | An inspectable baseline plus a learned residual (control.ladder) |
BD-198, BD-247 | The residual rung's steps against a specialist's are recorded on the corpus; KILL-RESIDUAL decided |
| BD-331 | The sampling controller at its gate | BD-252, BD-328 | GATE-REFLEX-06; KILL-MPC decided |
| BD-332 | The gait atlas and max-plus timing; A-04 (gait.atlas) |
BD-048, BD-110, BD-247 | Trot, pace and bound appear as (H, K) pairs for the quadruped and the tripod gait for the hexapod; GATE-ATEL-02 complete for A-01 to A-14 |
| BD-333 | Gaits as hybrid orbits: return maps, saltation, Floquet multipliers (gait.orbit); INT-FSIM-13 |
BD-161, BD-332 | GATE-GAIT-01; INT-FSIM-13 |
| BD-334 | Labeled derivatives through events (gait.gradient) |
BD-333 | GATE-GAIT-02 |
| BD-335 | Continuation of orbits in morphology, and orbit screening (gait.continue) |
BD-328, BD-333 | GATE-GAIT-03; KILL-GAIT decided |
| BD-336 | Skill artifacts .fskill, the exact layer (skill.compile, skill.check, skill.show) |
BD-251 | GATE-REFLEX-08 |
| BD-337 | The energy-budget safety tier .fenergy, with the exact-integer monitor K-energy-monitor and its proof kind (shield.budget) |
BD-053, BD-132, BD-208 | GATE-SHIELD-01; KILL-ENERGY decided |
| BD-338 | Runtime shields with a backup controller (shield.fit, shield.check) |
BD-251, BD-337 | GATE-SHIELD-02 |
| BD-339 | Shields on in-envelope and shifted worlds | BD-198, BD-338 | GATE-SHIELD-03; KILL-SHIELD decided |
| BD-340 | The measured shield margin with its drift alarm (shield.report) |
BD-339 | GATE-SHIELD-04 |
| BD-341 | Optimization and racing (opt.start, opt.status) |
BD-183, BD-262 | A null race keeps the best design with probability at least 1 − α; a race with a planted winner returns it |
| BD-342 | The quality-diversity archive and maps per dispatch (opt.archive, phylum.map) |
BD-287, BD-341 | GATE-PHYLUM-08; merging two agents' archives in both orders gives identical bytes |
| BD-343 | Lineage bisect and merge (design.bisect) |
BD-113, BD-262 | Bisect row of GATE-ATEL-04: the planted edit is found in at least 95 of 100 trials; bisect on a non-monotone predicate is refused |
| BD-344 | Registered predictions (predict.register, predict.report) |
BD-341 | A prediction registered after its outcome exists is refused; a report scores every registered prediction, the failed ones included |
| BD-345 | Screening audits: sampled discarded strata and the planted winner (nemesis.audit, applied by the cascade) |
BD-248, BD-329 | GATE-ATEL-09; GATE-NEMESIS-07 |
| BD-346 | Rank robustness of finalists inside the cascade (A-19) | BD-266, BD-329 | GATE-ATEL-10 |
| BD-347 | Revalidation grades 3 and 4 | BD-292 | GATE-ATEL-11; KILL-REUSE decided |
| BD-348 | The remaining analyses: A-24 task-wrench attainability, A-25 identifiability, A-26 regime atlas | BD-233, BD-265, BD-336 | GATE-ATEL-05; KILL-ATLAS decided |
| BD-349 | Decision-core tables DC-02 to DC-08 and DC-11 | BD-276, BD-282, BD-309, BD-329, BD-341 | GATE-ATEL-13 |
| BD-350 | Composition of decision cores: the nine interference tests | BD-349 | GATE-ATEL-14 |
| BD-351 | Experiment suggestion by value of information (experiment.suggest) |
BD-291, BD-341 | GATE-ATEL-15; GATE-AUGUR-11; KILL-VOI decided |
| BD-352 | The six-stage co-design cascade (opt.cascade, report.campaign) |
BD-260, BD-285, BD-329, BD-335, BD-342, BD-345, BD-346, BD-347 | GATE-ATEL-16; NS-06 demonstrated |
| BD-353 | Paired finite-difference design gradients (phylum.gradient) |
BD-183, BD-341 | GATE-PHYLUM-06; KILL-FDGRAD decided |
| BD-354 | The ceiling-before-speed check on every registered speed comparison | BD-135, BD-216 | GATE-AUGUR-14 |
| BD-355 | Mission queries over families on the GPU: the 65,536-row screen and a 1,024-design family batch under the exact-integer or guarded class | BD-135, BD-182, BD-183, BD-190 | GATE-AUGUR-15 |
| BD-356 | Design-family lanes (level P-C) with the speedup bound 1/(1 − f + f/r + h) | BD-354, BD-355 | Measured f, r and h are recorded on the strong baseline before any ratio is quoted; KILL-FAMILYLANE decided |
| BD-357 | Quotients, cuts and cell refinement in family search | BD-285, BD-355 | False cuts on the frozen catalog and the evaluation cost saved are recorded; KILL-AUGUR-CUTS decided |
| BD-358 | Region certificates on small sub-boxes | BD-289, BD-355 | GATE-AUGUR-09 |
| BD-359 | Product-system dominance | BD-135, BD-161 | GATE-AUGUR-16; KILL-AUGUR-DOMINANCE decided |
| BD-360 | The co-design fixed-point lane of frob-synth (mission.synthesize with strategy codesign) |
BD-103, BD-135 | Co-design rows of GATE-AUGUR-17; KILL-SYNTH-CODESIGN decided |
| BD-361 | Bounded exact linkage synthesis through the derivation subprocess, emitting a .fmodule (strategy linkage) |
BD-060, BD-101, BD-135 | Linkage rows of GATE-AUGUR-17; KILL-SYNTH-LINKAGE decided |
| BD-362 | Trajectory optimization with design variables (strategy refine) |
BD-135, BD-334 | GATE-AUGUR-18; KILL-SYNTH-TRAJOPT decided |
| BD-363 | Label queries on supplied command sets | BD-135 | GATE-AUGUR-19; KILL-AUGUR-LABELS decided |
| BD-364 | Mission bundles for family answers, re-checked on a second machine | BD-355, BD-358 | GATE-LEMMA-04 at M4 |
| BD-365 | Tyre laws, tracks and hybrids on all tiers | BD-245 | Known answers of §18.16 for these laws; NS-08 demonstrated |
| BD-366 | Soil mechanics: plate sinkage, drawbar pull, ruts as per-world mutable state (contact.soil) |
BD-365 | GATE-TRAC-08; KILL-SOIL decided |
| BD-367 | The contact response batch with per-column bounds and reroutes (contact.response) |
BD-168 | The share of columns the guard reroutes on battery states is recorded; KILL-RESPONSE decided |
| BD-368 | Moving surfaces and the task families of M4: conveyors, stair and curb climbing for wheels and tracks, reach and carry | BD-253, BD-365 | GATE-ARENA-01 for these families; a belt whose boundary work is left off the energy ledger is caught |
| BD-369 | The retrofit catalog registries/retrofits.toml with priced kits, and scene.retrofit on a .fmcw |
BD-227, BD-233, BD-274 | GATE-HAB-11; KILL-RETROFIT decided; NS-18 demonstrated |
| BD-370 | The fleet scheduler across the two machines (fleet.status, fleet.plan) |
BD-199, BD-296 | GATE-SPARK-13; KILL-FLEET decided |
| BD-371 | Specialized kernels for survivors | BD-217, BD-352 | GATE-SPARK-14; KILL-SPECIALIZE decided |
| BD-372 | The one-call pipeline solve.run, which calls opt.cascade |
BD-298, BD-352 | Second arm of GATE-TETHER-13, the same A/B as GATE-ATEL-03; KILL-SOLVE decided |
| BD-373 | The mission session with a fresh agent | BD-298, BD-355 | GATE-TETHER-13 |
| BD-374 | The agent-surface A/B on the design benchmark | BD-298, BD-352 | GATE-ATEL-03 |
| BD-375 | Autopsy against logs and explain alone, with agents on the planted-defect designs |
BD-248, BD-284, BD-298 | GATE-AUTOPSY-08 |
| BD-376 | The M4 verbs with schemas, examples and refusal lists | BD-312, BD-322, BD-323, BD-327, BD-330, BD-331, BD-334, BD-335, BD-340, BD-343, BD-344, BD-348, BD-351, BD-352, BD-353, BD-360, BD-361, BD-362, BD-363, BD-366, BD-367, BD-369, BD-370, BD-372 | GATE-TETHER-02 for the M4 verbs |
| BD-377 | frob-conformance for M4: the calibration sets, the frozen 30-amendment campaign, the seeded cascade population |
BD-318, BD-350, BD-352, BD-364 | GATE-GAUNT-01 for M4 |
| BD-378 | M4 exit review by a fresh-context session that did not implement the work | BD-319, BD-324, BD-326, BD-356, BD-357, BD-359, BD-368, BD-371, BD-373, BD-374, BD-375, BD-376, BD-377 | Every gate of M4 has a recorded value and a caught negative control; rank agreement is measured and the family-policy bets are decided |
45.6 M5: proofs, reality, manufacture
The Reality lane is an import lane. BD-397 closes on a record or on a recorded no-claim, and no bead waits for bench
data (§30.17).
| Bead | Title | Depends on | Done when |
|---|---|---|---|
| BD-379 | Certificate coverage for derived kernels | BD-027, BD-221 | GATE-LEMMA-01; KILL-LEMMA decided; NS-11 demonstrated |
| BD-380 | INT-FLN-01 and INT-FLN-02: the Lean project under lean/ and the fln checker on a Linux host |
BD-001 | INT-FLN-01; INT-FLN-02: a true port identity is admitted and its sign-mutated twin is rejected |
| BD-381 | Lean theorem cards as sealed capsules (proof kind lean-capsule) |
BD-027, BD-380 | GATE-LEMMA-02 |
| BD-382 | The reflection pilot: Farkas and rational LDLᵀ reflectors (prove.reflect) |
BD-132, BD-381 | GATE-LEMMA-05; KILL-REFLECT decided |
| BD-383 | Qualification campaigns replayed by frob-verify |
BD-132, BD-260 | GATE-QUAL-03 |
| BD-384 | The articulated variational integrator on the referee and the strict profile |
BD-087, BD-161 | Momentum and energy known answers of §16.16; cost at matched accuracy recorded against the factor-two limit; KILL-VARIATIONAL decided |
| BD-385 | The tree-operator route for larger mechanisms and limb port packets, as a pilot | BD-060, BD-159 | The pilot's result is on file with PO-SKEL-04; KILL-TREEOP and KILL-SKEL-PORT decided |
| BD-386 | The hard-contact law CL-H as a batch law on batch-cpu |
BD-154, BD-161, BD-266 | GATE-TRAC-09 on batch-cpu; KILL-HARDCONTACT decided |
| BD-387 | Ground data admission: the dataset manifest (frob.ground.dataset/1), cells, sealed validation and holdout splits (ground.ingest) |
BD-007, BD-090, BD-305 | A dataset with no declared cell is refused; a read of a sealed split before its prediction is frozen is refused |
| BD-388 | The synthetic rehearsal: a synthetic dataset generated with planted parameters |
BD-187, BD-208, BD-387 | The known answers of §30.21 reproduce; every output of the rehearsal prints synthetic in its evidence |
| BD-389 | Clock fitting | BD-078, BD-388 | GATE-GROUND-02; KILL-CLOCK decided |
| BD-390 | Identifiability analysis and excitation design (ground.excite) |
BD-348, BD-388 | GATE-GROUND-03 |
| BD-391 | Identification, actuators first, and card updates from logs (ground.identify) |
BD-069, BD-389, BD-390 | GATE-GROUND-04; KILL-GROUND decided |
| BD-392 | Frozen predictions, sealed trials and holdout retirement (ground.predict, ground.score) |
BD-344, BD-387 | GATE-GROUND-05 |
| BD-393 | Conformal reality bands per calibrated cell, with the DC-07 table (ground.band) |
BD-391, BD-392 | GATE-GROUND-06 |
| BD-394 | Drift detection that retires a calibration | BD-393 | GATE-GROUND-07; KILL-BAND decided |
| BD-395 | As-built ingestion | BD-062, BD-387 | GATE-GROUND-08; KILL-ASBUILT decided |
| BD-396 | The replication kit (ground.kit) |
BD-305, BD-392 | GATE-GROUND-09; KILL-KIT decided |
| BD-397 | The Reality lane's first record | BD-393, BD-394 | GATE-GROUND-10: a frozen prediction scored on sealed data with a band issued, or a recorded no-claim with its reason |
| BD-398 | Real-place ingestion (scene.import, scene.fit); INT-FDGR-01 |
BD-228, BD-291, BD-305 | GATE-HAB-03; INT-FDGR-01; KILL-INGEST decided |
| BD-399 | Asset-populated interiors with their licences | BD-226, BD-305 | A populated scene keeps the launch shape and the determinism class of its batch; KILL-DRESSING decided |
| BD-400 | Load cases and spectra extracted from T2 telemetry (foundry.loads) |
BD-207, BD-260 | GATE-FOUNDRY-02; KILL-LOADS decided |
| BD-401 | The beam-rung sizing check and A-15 structural margin (foundry.size); INT-FSIM-15 |
BD-400 | GATE-FOUNDRY-01; INT-FSIM-15 |
| BD-402 | Stress, buckling, modes and cumulative fatigue damage | BD-401 | GATE-FOUNDRY-03 |
| BD-403 | Topology optimization of links (foundry.optimize) |
BD-401 | GATE-FOUNDRY-04; GATE-FOUNDRY-05; KILL-TOPOPT decided |
| BD-404 | Inertia fed back into the model as a typed edit, with the convergence test | BD-058, BD-403 | GATE-FOUNDRY-06 |
| BD-405 | Manufacturability checks (foundry.check) |
BD-403 | GATE-FOUNDRY-07; KILL-FAB decided |
| BD-406 | Tolerance allocation driven by sensitivities (foundry.tolerance) |
BD-401 | GATE-FOUNDRY-08; KILL-TOLERANCE decided |
| BD-407 | Bounded geometry export | BD-405 | GATE-FOUNDRY-09 |
| BD-408 | The build packet .fbuild with its four flags (foundry.export) |
BD-303, BD-346, BD-402, BD-404, BD-406, BD-407 | GATE-FOUNDRY-10; KILL-PACKET decided; NS-20 demonstrated |
| BD-409 | The M5 verbs with schemas, examples and refusal lists | BD-376, BD-379, BD-382, BD-395, BD-396, BD-397, BD-398, BD-408 | GATE-TETHER-02 for the M5 verbs |
| BD-410 | The format registry complete for all thirteen formats | BD-141, BD-162, BD-233, BD-274, BD-336, BD-337, BD-408 | GATE-WS-02 |
| BD-411 | frob-conformance for M5: the certificate mutation corpora, the synthetic rehearsal, the structure fixtures |
BD-377, BD-382, BD-397, BD-408 | GATE-GAUNT-01 for M5 |
| BD-412 | M5 exit review by a fresh-context session that did not implement the work | BD-378, BD-383, BD-384, BD-385, BD-386, BD-399, BD-409, BD-410, BD-411 | Every gate of M5 has a recorded value and a caught negative control; the Reality lane has a record or a recorded no-claim |
45.7 M6: frontier physics (epics)
Each row is an epic, split into tasks when M6 opens. None is on a critical path. An epic whose mechanism has no gate in §40 writes its kill gate and its fallback as part of its plan. The cap of four active Moonshot items (D-6) applies to the M epics here and in §45.9.
| Bead | Title | Depends on | Done when |
|---|---|---|---|
| BD-413 | Epic: robot-advected films; INT-FSIM-17 | BD-230 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GATE-HAB-07; INT-FSIM-17 |
| BD-414 | Epic: payload slosh by an equivalent mechanical model | BD-231 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; slosh rows of GATE-HAB-08; KILL-SLOSH decided |
| BD-415 | Epic: articulated proxies, a cord as a chain of links and a rug as hinged plates | BD-231 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; proxy rows of GATE-HAB-08; GATE-HAB-09 reported; KILL-PROXY decided |
| BD-416 | Epic: Cosserat rods, cloth and coupled multiphysics islands on the CPU referee, for finalists only; INT-FTX-01 | BD-413, BD-415 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; INT-FTX-01; KILL-LIVING decided |
| BD-417 | Epic: soft soil at scale | BD-366 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; rut state stays per-world with zero leak over 10³ resets at batch scale |
| BD-418 | Epic: tactile sensing and compliant pads | BD-167, BD-187 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; a kill gate and its fallback are written before any work package is funded |
| BD-419 | Epic: the rotor port for flight | BD-071, BD-159 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; the hover known answer and the port balance; KILL-SINEW-ROTOR decided |
| BD-420 | Epic: RGB and splat scenes | BD-187, BD-398 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; a kill gate and its fallback are written before any work package is funded |
| BD-421 | Epic: moving people as kinematic actors on route graphs | BD-399 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; no claim about human behaviour is issued from an actor |
| BD-422 | Epic: gradients through contact | BD-334, BD-353 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; every derivative carries its validity label, and a gradient at a grazing event is labeled or refused |
| BD-423 | Epic: lifecycle compression (foundry.lifecycle) |
BD-391, BD-402 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GATE-FOUNDRY-12; KILL-LIFECYCLE and KILL-SINEW-AGE decided |
| BD-424 | Epic: the hard-contact law on GPU tiers | BD-172, BD-174, BD-386 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GPU rows of GATE-TRAC-09 |
| BD-425 | Epic: geometric phase for locomotion | BD-243, BD-332 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GATE-AUGUR-20; KILL-AUGUR-PHASE decided |
| BD-426 | Epic: symmetry at the instant of contact | BD-327, BD-334 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GATE-AUGUR-21; KILL-AUGUR-SYMEVENT decided |
| BD-427 | M6 exit review by a fresh-context session that did not implement the work | BD-412, BD-414, BD-416, BD-417, BD-418, BD-419, BD-420, BD-421, BD-422, BD-423, BD-424, BD-425, BD-426 | Every epic of M6 has its plan, its pilot result and its kill-gate decision on record; every gate reached has a recorded value and a caught negative control |
45.8 M7: the ten-fold tournament (epics)
One group of epics for the test of §39. The suite is sealed before either arm runs, and the result is published whatever the ratio.
| Bead | Title | Depends on | Done when |
|---|---|---|---|
| BD-428 | Epic: the sealed suite: missions in named strata, sealed worlds including externally authored ones, the crossover reuse count | BD-317, BD-378 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; the suite's commitment hash is published before either arm sees it |
| BD-429 | Epic: the tournament decision rule: the pooled ratio of restricted mean times, 24 mission families per cell for a finite-suite result and at least 32 for a population result (§39.20), the power analysis against a true ratio of 10, the written kill rules | BD-124, BD-317 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; the reachable verdicts are enumerated before sampling, and a rule that cannot return one of its verdicts at the planned n is rejected |
| BD-430 | Epic: the incumbent arms: the strongest composed rival at pinned versions, cold and warm, including a short robust program over an incumbent engine | BD-039, BD-301, BD-428 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; the rival's phase ledger is recorded on trj under the disclosure block |
| BD-431 | Epic: our arm: fresh agents on the released surface, cold and warm runs separated | BD-412, BD-428 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; every phase of every campaign is in the phase ledger, and one false certificate disqualifies the arm |
| BD-432 | Epic: neutral adjudication of accepted answers | BD-383, BD-429, BD-430, BD-431 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; an answer is accepted only by the adjudicator, and a planted false acceptance in a dry run is caught |
| BD-433 | Epic: publication of the result | BD-432 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; the measured ratio is published with its phase ledger whatever it is, and a tie with a short robust program over an incumbent is reported as a tie (BET-14) |
| BD-434 | M7 exit review by a fresh-context session that did not implement the work | BD-427, BD-433 | Every gate of the ten-fold test due at M7 (GATE-TENFOLD-03 to -05 repeated, -07, -08, -11, -12, -13) has a recorded value and a caught negative control; the measured ratio is published with its phase ledger |
45.9 M8: frontier delivery (epics)
Each row is an epic with its stop rule. The M items wait their turn under the cap of four, and a kill gate that fires ends its epic with the fallback and no further work.
| Bead | Title | Depends on | Done when |
|---|---|---|---|
| BD-435 | Epic: facility co-design and multi-robot handoff | BD-352, BD-363, BD-369 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GATE-AUGUR-24; KILL-AUGUR-FACILITY decided |
| BD-436 | Epic: skill transport. skill.transport moves a skill artifact with a learned residual M; mission.transport moves a certified claim through an interface map with a bounded error F |
BD-321, BD-336 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GATE-AUGUR-23; GATE-REFLEX-09; KILL-SKILL and KILL-AUGUR-TRANSPORT decided |
| BD-437 | Epic: continuation-based synthesis (strategy continuation) |
BD-361 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GATE-AUGUR-22; KILL-SYNTH-CONT decided |
| BD-438 | Epic: firmware export | BD-338, BD-408 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GATE-FOUNDRY-11; KILL-FIRMWARE decided |
| BD-439 | Epic: geometric-algebra tree policies at scale | BD-321, BD-325 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GATE-CORTEX-17; KILL-GATREE decided |
| BD-440 | Epic: reachable-set tables for shields | BD-338 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; GATE-SHIELD-05; KILL-TUBE decided |
| BD-441 | Epic: the fused per-world step kernel | BD-217 | A short plan exists and its pilot has run; the paired lower bound on the whole step is recorded with digests unchanged; KILL-MEGA decided |
| BD-442 | M8 exit review by a fresh-context session that did not implement the work | BD-434, BD-435, BD-436, BD-437, BD-438, BD-439, BD-440, BD-441 | Every epic of M8 has its plan, its pilot result and its stop rule applied; every gate reached has a recorded value and a caught negative control |
45.10 Graph facts
FACT, checked mechanically on the tables as printed:
- Size. 442 beads: 406 tasks, 27 epics and 9 exit reviews. By milestone: M0 44, M1 103, M2 77, M3 95, M4 59, M5 34, M6 15, M7 7, M8 8. The graph has 1,091 dependency edges and one root, BD-001.
- No cycles. Every dependency points to a lower-numbered bead. The numbering is therefore a topological order, and the graph has no cycles.
- Exit reviews. Every bead of a milestone is an ancestor of that milestone's exit review, and each exit review depends on the one before it: BD-044 → BD-147 → BD-224 → BD-319 → BD-378 → BD-412 → BD-427 → BD-434 → BD-442. BD-442 therefore has every other bead as an ancestor.
- Beads with no consumer other than exit reviews. 44 beads. M0: BD-002, BD-037, BD-038; M1: BD-140; M2: none; M3: BD-256, BD-257, BD-268, BD-300, BD-311; M4: BD-324, BD-326, BD-356, BD-357, BD-359, BD-368, BD-371, BD-373, BD-374, BD-375; M5: BD-384, BD-385, BD-409, BD-410, BD-411; M6: BD-414, BD-416, BD-417, BD-418, BD-419, BD-420, BD-421, BD-422, BD-423, BD-424, BD-425, BD-426; M7: BD-433; M8: BD-435, BD-436, BD-437, BD-438, BD-439, BD-440, BD-441. These are gate-closing measurements, agent tests and frontier epics. Nothing later is built on them, so only the exit review of their milestone waits for them, and it does.
- Longest chain. 37 beads: BD-001 → 005 → 014 → 016 → 031 → 054 → 056 → 061 → 070 → 080 → 081 → 082 → 084 → 155 → 159 → 192 → 194 → 201 → 202 → 212 → 263 → 272 → 273 → 274 → 275 → 312 → 313 → 316 → 317 → 319 → 378 → 428 → 430 → 432 → 433 → 434 → 442. In words: workspace, core types, kernel backend, Metal admission, the toolchain matrix, the design term and its model, actuators, the transactional referee step with joint rows, the batched step, the environment and its tasks, the frozen battery and the promotion rule, Nemesis from its guard to the hard-world set, the M3 verbs and the agent documentation, the partial ten-fold gate, the exit reviews of M3 and M4, the tournament, and the last two exit reviews.
- Longest chain that uses no exit review. 33 beads: the same chain to BD-317, then BD-428 → BD-430 → BD-432 → BD-433.
- Widest beads. BD-312 and BD-376, the verbs of M3 and M4, with 24 dependencies each. Exit reviews have between 2 and 16 dependencies.
- Gate coverage. Each of the 421 identifiers of the gate inventory (278 convergence gates, 111 kill gates, 32 admission gates) is cited by at least one bead, as are the five sibling admission gates of §33.15 and GATE-GAUNT-01. 118 beads cite no gate, kill gate or admission gate: they are building blocks, pilots, reports and exit reviews whose observable is stated in full in the row.
Gates that close in parts, or at a milestone other than the earliest one their chapter names:
| Gate | Earliest in its chapter | Closed by |
|---|---|---|
| GATE-SPARK-21 | M1 | The trj rows at M0 (BD-040); complete at M1 (BD-142) |
| GATE-KIN-04, GATE-TRAC-01, GATE-TRAC-06 | M1, strict included |
Referee rows at M1 (BD-083, BD-085, BD-086); strict rows at M2 (BD-161); batched rows at M2 (BD-168) |
| GATE-SENS-04, GATE-SENS-05, GATE-SENS-12 | M2 | CPU and referee rows at M1 (BD-078, BD-098, BD-119), because the mission slice needs them; every tier at M2 (BD-189, BD-215) |
| GATE-SENS-08, GATE-SENS-09 | M3 | Linearized and docking rows at M1 (BD-120, BD-134); complete at M3 (BD-239, BD-240) |
| GATE-MARROW-03, GATE-SKEL-03, GATE-SKEL-07 | None stated | Rows for the first four archetypes at M1 (BD-109, BD-118); complete at M3, when all eighteen exist (BD-246, BD-247) |
| GATE-ATEL-02 | M1 | The included analyses at M1 (BD-110); complete at M4 with A-04 (BD-332) |
| GATE-ATEL-04 | M3 | The comparison row at M3 (BD-262); the bisect row at M4 (BD-343) |
| GATE-FID-07 | M2 | Recorded at the M2 exit from the sampler's run (BD-214); repeated at M3 with the tier-correction ledger, where KILL-SHADOW is decided (BD-268) |
| GATE-AUGUR-11 | M4 | The probe pilot and KILL-AUGUR-PROBE at M3 (BD-291); the gate is recorded at M4 with experiment suggestion (BD-351) |
| GATE-ATEL-11 | M1 for mission cells, M3, M4 | Dependency grades 1 and 2 on mission cells at M1, inside the amendment fixtures of the mission slice (BD-135, BD-136); the engine and its dependency-grade rows at M3 (BD-292); grades 3 and 4 at M4 (BD-347) |
| GATE-ARENA-04 | M1 on the referee, M2 on the batch tiers | Referee rows at M1 (BD-123); batch-tier rows at M2 (BD-212) |
| GATE-REFLEX-01 | M1, M2, M3, M4 | The first archetypes on the referee at M1 (BD-118); the same set on batch-cpu at M2; every archetype except tracked and hybrid at M3 (BD-247); tracked and hybrid at M4 with their contact laws |
| GATE-CORTEX-12, GATE-ATEL-07, GATE-ATEL-08 | M3 as a pilot, M4 | The pilot at M3 (BD-310); on our engine at M4 (BD-328, BD-329) |
| GATE-REFLEX-06 | M4 | The controller lands at M3 as a fallback (BD-252); the gate closes at M4 (BD-331) |
| GATE-AUGUR-09 | M3 | The pilot and the kill decision at M3 (BD-289); the gate closes at M4 (BD-358) |
| GATE-HAB-11 | M3 | M4 (BD-369), with the retrofit catalog |
| GATE-SHIELD-01 | M3 | M4 (BD-337), with the energy-budget tier |
| GATE-TRAC-09 | M3 on batch-cpu |
M5 (BD-386), with the hard-contact batch law; GPU rows in the M6 epic BD-424 |
| GATE-FOUNDRY-01, -02, -03; GATE-GROUND-03 | M4 | M5 (BD-401, BD-400, BD-402, BD-390), with Foundry and Ground |
| GATE-FOUNDRY-12 | M8 | The M6 epic BD-423 |
45.11 Conversion rules
Each row becomes one br issue: a task for M0 to M5 and for every exit review, an epic for the other rows of M6 to
M8. The BD number is kept as the issue's reference, "Depends on" becomes its blocking dependencies, and labels carry
the milestone, the owning crate of §34.2, the tier and the work package. bv --robot-* triages the result (§34.7).
The rules below are DESIGN.
- What a bead inherits. Every bead inherits the definition of "implemented" (§0.2) for the capability it delivers,
and the false-progress guards of §38: typed close reasons, negative controls, live-dependency proofs, the
syntheticlabel, behaviour and not plumbing, no self-certification. A bead that delivers part of a capability states which clauses of §0.2 stay open, and the capability is described as partial until the bead that closes its gate is closed. - How a bead closes. With a typed reason that cites its own test and that test's output: a line in its log
docs/delivery/logs/<bead>.ndjson(frob.beadlog/1, §29.14) whose verdict ispass, whose claim identifiers resolve in the artifact graph, and whose recording session is not the session that implemented the bead. A close reason shared by several beads is a failure signal, and the exit review rejects it. A closed bead is not acceptance (§0.7); acceptance is the gate's row inregistries/gates.toml. - Kill gates. A bead whose kill gate fires closes with the reason
fallbackand the name of the fallback. Its dependents are then re-read: one that needs the killed capability closes with the reasonsupersededand the identifier of the ADR; one that can stand on the fallback keeps its dependency. - Work packages. Work packages (§44) group beads by crate and milestone. A bead belongs to exactly one: the package that owns its crate at its milestone or, where a bead touches several crates, the package that owns the crate in which its gate is measured. Exit reviews belong to none.
- Pilots and compute. A bead for an F or M mechanism is not ready until the pilot of its chapter has a recorded result (§0.7). A bead whose run exceeds the machine envelope of §34.7 (the parity baselines, training, the head-to-head, the rank-agreement experiment, the partial gate, the tournament) names its budget and is not ready until the owner's approval under OPEN-SPARK-2 is recorded.
- Splitting and adding. A bead too large for one session is split into children that carry its number with a
suffix (BD-nnn.1, BD-nnn.2). The children inherit its dependencies, and the parent closes when its last child
closes. A bead discovered during implementation takes the next free number and depends only on existing beads, and
the exit review of its milestone gains it as a dependency. That is the one case in which a dependency may point to a
higher number. After conversion the guarantee against cycles is
br's cycle check, not the numbering. - Exit reviews. An exit review implements nothing. It closes when every gate of its milestone has a recorded value
and a caught negative control in
registries/gates.toml(GATE-GAUNT-01), every kill gate due at the milestone has its ADR, and the honest-status table regenerates from the logs.
45.12 Subsections added by the audits, to be placed during conversion
The subsections below were added by the completeness audits after the bead tables were compiled. During conversion each becomes one or more beads in the milestone of its gate, with the same done-condition form: its gate records a value and its negative control is caught. Until then they are not counted in the graph facts above.
| Subsection | Title | Gates it names |
|---|---|---|
| §23.25 | The joint law of sampled actions | GATE-CORTEX-18 |
| §23.26 | The actor's information contract covers every field it can read | GATE-CORTEX-19 |
| §23.27 | A threshold crossing is not attainment | GATE-CORTEX-05, GATE-CORTEX-20 |
| §39.20 | Estimating the ratio, and the smallest suite that can certify | GATE-TENFOLD-10 |
| §39.21 | Rival arms, protocol controls and the sealed suite | GATE-TENFOLD-11, GATE-TENFOLD-12 |
| §25.29 | Chance claims transport only through a coupling | GATE-AUGUR-25, KILL-COUPLING |
| §25.30 | No monotone fill without a proof of monotonicity | GATE-AUGUR-26 |
| §24.19 | Traction capacity is a slice of the wrench set at the commanded wrench | GATE-ARENA-10 |
| §29.22 | The solver's kinetic-energy correction is not heat | GATE-CHRON-14 |
| §20.23 | Force sensors act on a force history: filter, clip and integrate in a declared order | GATE-SENS-15 |
| §13.11 | A circle-valued joint needs periodic laws, or its turn count | GATE-MARROW-06 |
| §34.14 | The canonical reader and writer, and JSON features that unify across the build | GATE-WS-05 |
| §33.17 | Further foundation facts and their admission tests | GATE-WS-06 |
| §21.26 | Counts beyond 2³² without 64-bit atomics | GATE-SPARK-23 |
| §41.5 | Four risks that follow from late foundation facts | GATE-WS-07 |
| §47.4 | The order in which evidence is procured, and complete dispositions | GATE-WS-08 |
| §38.17 | Known answers adopted from corrected fixtures | GATE-FID-09 |
| §32.23 | The agent diagnosis battery | GATE-TETHER-01, GATE-TETHER-13, GATE-TETHER-15 |
| §14.16 | Module capability tables and the composed quasi-static screen | GATE-SKEL-09, GATE-SKEL-10, KILL-SKEL-CELL |
| §16.19 | Row-class solve queues | GATE-KIN-08, KILL-ROWQUEUE |
| §16.20 | Decoupled stepping of separated robots in one world | GATE-KIN-09, KILL-INTERACT |
| §16.21 | Step adjoints through the converged contact solve | GATE-KIN-10, KILL-STEPADJOINT |
| §16.22 | Closed-form elimination of single-loop planar closures | GATE-KIN-11, KILL-LOOPELIM |
| §16.23 | Ancestor-sparse assembly and the solve-stage ledger | GATE-KIN-12, KILL-ANCESTOR, KILL-TREEOP |
| §17.21 | Limb-archetype kernels | GATE-PHYLUM-09, KILL-LIMBKERNEL |
| §18.19 | Response batches: anchor, acceptance, known answers, gate | GATE-TRAC-11, KILL-RESPONSE |
| §19.21 | Far-field field reuse across forks | GATE-HAB-15, KILL-FARFIELD |
| §20.24 | Visibility under self-occlusion, and sensor mounts as design variables | GATE-SENS-16, GATE-SENS-17, KILL-VISIBILITY |
| §22.20 | A lifted linear planning model for one soft-soil regime | GATE-REFLEX-10, KILL-SOILLIFT |
| §22.21 | The pre-slip aliasing fixture and the sampled-data backup domain | GATE-SHIELD-06 |
| §22.22 | The sampling controller as the delivered controller | GATE-REFLEX-11, KILL-MPCRECORD |
| §23.28 | The winner check for a selecting rung | GATE-CORTEX-21 |
| §23.29 | Short-horizon gradient training with design parameters | GATE-CORTEX-22, KILL-SHORTGRAD |
| §24.20 | Auditing a task before any design runs on it: foil bodies and intent invariants | GATE-ARENA-11, KILL-FOIL |
| §24.21 | The item bank: importance sampling of battery items for close comparisons | GATE-ARENA-12, GATE-ARENA-13, KILL-ITEMBANK |
| §24.22 | Exposure domains and the coupling test | GATE-ARENA-14, KILL-COUPLING |
| §25.31 | Monomial screens in exponent coordinates | GATE-AUGUR-27 |
| §25.32 | Utility brackets and the dominance stop | GATE-AUGUR-28, KILL-AUGUR-BRACKET |
| §25.33 | Placement and sizing along a prescribed motion | GATE-AUGUR-29, KILL-SYNTH-REGRESSOR |
| §25.34 | Weak-variable enclosure and the split set | GATE-AUGUR-30, KILL-WEAKVAR |
| §27.19 | Attribution in single precision on the originating tier | GATE-AUTOPSY-03, GATE-AUTOPSY-09, KILL-ENSEMBLE |
| §28.25 | Controller-budget curves and the controller-limited label | GATE-ATEL-17, GATE-ATEL-18, KILL-BUDGETCURVE |
| §28.26 | The reuse ledger: three columns, never summed | GATE-ATEL-19 |
| §31.21 | Packet review as an imported record | GATE-FOUNDRY-13, KILL-PACKET |
| §31.22 | Referee re-extraction of load cases that enter a build packet | GATE-FOUNDRY-14 |
| §31.23 | Member sizing as a validity check in screening | GATE-FOUNDRY-15 |
| §32.24 | The offline replay packet | GATE-TETHER-16, KILL-REPLAYPACK |
| §39.22 | Three arms, the recovery ratio and the phase ablations | GATE-TENFOLD-13 |
| §25.35 | The controller class is part of a family answer | GATE-AUGUR-31 |
| §25.36 | Docking to a finite tolerance over a continuous gain interval | GATE-AUGUR-32 |
| §25.37 | Channel laws: the joint error law of repeated reads, and the code that carries a label | GATE-AUGUR-33 |
| §25.38 | Shared nuisance parameters, and the probe for four admitted laws | GATE-AUGUR-34, KILL-AUGUR-PROBE |
| §25.39 | Sizing witnesses for fixed points, and Pareto coverage of a catalog | GATE-AUGUR-35 |
| §14.17 | Folding fixed joints, and reduced models | GATE-SKEL-11 |
| §15.15 | Coupled transmissions: the torque set, the rotor energy and the direction witness | GATE-SINEW-10 |
| §16.24 | A held command and the step that integrates it | GATE-KIN-13 |
| §18.20 | Swept bounds enclose arcs | GATE-TRAC-12 |
| §19.22 | Scaled instances: distances, normals and ray parameters in world metres | GATE-HAB-16 |
| §20.25 | Sampled readings: impacts in an exposure, encoder unwrapping, the load-cell cut | GATE-SENS-18 |
| §22.23 | Orbits of a loop with no clock: the free period and the trivial multiplier | GATE-GAIT-01, GATE-GAIT-04, KILL-FREEPERIOD |
| §22.24 | Stability over admitted sequences of strides | GATE-GAIT-05, KILL-STRIDESEQ |
| §22.25 | Sampled damping, and the work of a held command | GATE-SHIELD-07 |
| §24.23 | The idle arm of the task audit | GATE-ARENA-15 |
| §30.24 | Exposure delay and mount translation on a straight pass | GATE-GROUND-03, GATE-GROUND-11 |
| §33.18 | Six later foundation facts and their admission tests | GATE-WS-09 |
| §38.18 | Known answers adopted from late fixtures | GATE-GAUNT-11 |