Worked artifacts
7,940 words9 subsections5 tables9 listingsPlan version 1.1
On this page9
Nine artifacts for one story: a quadruped that carries a tray through a commercial-kitchen galley and sets it down at
a pass counter. They are DESIGN specimens. Every number is illustrative of the format and is not a result; where an
artifact contains arithmetic, the arithmetic is exact and was recomputed for this appendix (Appendix H.5). Identities
are abbreviated (d:7a3e…). Each artifact uses the schema of the chapter that owns it. Where a chapter fixes the
contents of a section and not the spelling of its fields, the artifact says so and the spellings shown are proposals
confined to the listed contents.
The story in one paragraph. A static mission query asks which stance half-widths and knee ratios can support the loaded tray; its answer has an inner set, an outer set and a band of unresolved cells (L.4). A design is created at the centre of an inner cell (L.1), with its leg as a reusable module (L.2). The dynamic task is the tray delivery (L.3). A search for adversarial worlds finds a failure and shrinks it to three edits (L.6); an interventional autopsy says which of them can be undone to rescue the run (L.9). After one design edit a paired study compares the versions (L.8), an energy budget bounds what a stop at the counter can deliver (L.5), the blinded lane qualifies the design (L.9), and the certificates and the receipt travel in one bundle (L.7).
L.1 A .fbot design: quad-tray
Schema frob.design/1 (§14.4). The design is written as authored; the canonical form sorts keys, removes white space
and writes out every default (§14.4, seven rules). The half-width 1/7 m has no terminating decimal and is therefore
written as a ratio (rule 3).
{ "schema": "frob.design/1", "name": "quad-tray",
"meta": { "author": "agent-17", "licence": "CC0-1.0", "source": "mission q:3c9d…, cell c:06a, centre" },
"root": { "body": "torso", "region": {"box": ["0.46 m", "0.24 m", "0.10 m"]},
"fill": {"shell": "2.5 mm"}, "material": "al-6061-t6",
"ports": { "hip_mount": {"xyz": ["0.20 m", "1/7 m", "0 m"]},
"tray_mount": {"xyz": ["0 m", "0 m", "0.05 m"]} } },
"limbs": { "mirror": "xz", "of": { "mirror": "yz", "of": {
"attach": "torso.hip_mount",
"chain": [
{ "joint": {"class": "R", "axis": [1,0,0], "limits": ["-45 deg", "45 deg"]}, "actuator": "qdd-m",
"body": {"region": {"capsule": ["0.03 m", "0.06 m"]}, "fill": "solid", "material": "al-6061-t6"} },
{ "joint": {"class": "R", "axis": [0,1,0], "limits": ["-90 deg", "150 deg"]}, "actuator": "qdd-m",
"body": {"region": {"capsule": ["0.025 m", "0.21 m"]}, "fill": {"shell": "2 mm"},
"material": "al-6061-t6"} },
{ "joint": {"class": "R", "axis": [0,1,0], "limits": ["-160 deg", "-30 deg"]}, "actuator": "qdd-l",
"transmission": {"belt": {"ratio": "2.35"}},
"body": {"region": {"capsule": ["0.02 m", "0.21 m"]}, "fill": {"shell": "1.5 mm"},
"material": "cfrp-ud"} },
{ "foot": {"region": {"sphere": "0.022 m"}, "fill": "solid", "material": "rubber-60a",
"contact": {"law": "foot-patch", "interface": "rubber-60a/default",
"torsion_radius": "8 mm"}} } ] } } },
"payloads": [ { "body": "tray", "region": {"box": ["0.40 m", "0.30 m", "0.03 m"]}, "fill": {"shell": "2 mm"},
"material": "pp-homopolymer", "mount": "torso.tray_mount", "removable": true } ],
"power_bus": { "id": "main", "battery": "li-6s-5ah", "nominal": "22.2 V", "current_max": "60 A",
"regen": "to-battery", "sink": {"conductance": "1.6 W/K"} },
"sensors": [ {"id": "imu", "card": "imu-generic", "parent": "torso", "rate": "500 Hz", "clock": "mcu"},
{"id": "enc", "card": "encoder-14b", "parent": "joints:*", "rate": "1000 Hz", "clock": "mcu"},
{"id": "fc", "card": "foot-contact", "parent": "feet:*", "rate": "500 Hz", "clock": "mcu"},
{"id": "lidar", "card": "lidar-2d-generic", "parent": "torso",
"mount": {"xyz": ["0.21 m", "0 m", "0.06 m"]}, "rate": "10 Hz", "clock": "lidar"} ],
"budgets": { "mass_max": "14 kg", "cost_max": "4000 USD", "power_peak_max": "900 W",
"envelope_max": ["0.70 m", "0.40 m", "0.50 m"], "payload_min": "2 kg" },
"levers": [ {"id": "half_width", "path": "/root/ports/hip_mount/xyz/1",
"bounds": ["1/12 m", "1/4 m"], "manifold": "R+"},
{"id": "knee_ratio", "path": "/limbs/of/of/chain/2/transmission/belt/ratio",
"bounds": ["1.0", "2.5"], "manifold": "R+"},
{"id": "foot_radius", "path": "/limbs/of/of/chain/3/foot/region/sphere",
"bounds": ["0.018 m", "0.032 m"], "manifold": "R+"} ],
"locks": ["power_bus", "payloads"],
"symmetry": {"assert_mech": "C2xC2", "assert_obs": "C2"} }
What the compiler derives and checks (§14.9, §14.11): twelve actuated coordinates; feet at (±1/5, ±1/7) m in the
nominal stance; Γ_mech = C₂ × C₂ from the two nested mirror constructors, with the centred tray preserving both
mirrors; Γ_obs = C₂ because the forward lidar breaks the fore–aft mirror. The archetype is quad-mammal (Appendix
G.4). Fills are explicit on every body (there is no default fill), and inertia is derived from Region, fill and
material.
L.2 An .fmodule: the three-joint leg and its port contract
Schema frob.module/1 (§14.6). The module is the leg of L.1 extracted by a typed edit, referenced by content hash as
"std/leg-3r-qdd.fmodule@b3:9a4e…".
{ "schema": "frob.module/1", "name": "leg-3r-qdd",
"ports": [ {"id": "mount", "kind": "mech", "frame": "hip_mount", "power": "into-module"},
{"id": "bus", "kind": "elec", "nominal": "22.2 V", "power": "into-module"},
{"id": "sink", "kind": "thermal", "power": "into-module"},
{"id": "state", "kind": "signal", "msg": "joint-state/3", "rate": "1000 Hz",
"latency_max": "1 ms"},
{"id": "sole", "kind": "contact", "law": "foot-patch"} ],
"params": [ {"id": "thigh", "unit": "m", "default": "0.21 m", "bounds": ["0.15 m", "0.30 m"]},
{"id": "knee_card", "kind": "card:actuator", "default": "qdd-l"} ],
"body": { "chain": [
{ "joint": {"class": "R", "axis": [1,0,0], "limits": ["-45 deg", "45 deg"]}, "actuator": "qdd-m",
"body": {"region": {"capsule": ["0.03 m", "0.06 m"]}, "fill": "solid", "material": "al-6061-t6"} },
{ "joint": {"class": "R", "axis": [0,1,0], "limits": ["-90 deg", "150 deg"]}, "actuator": "qdd-m",
"body": {"region": {"capsule": ["0.025 m", "0.21 m"]}, "fill": {"shell": "2 mm"},
"material": "al-6061-t6"} },
{ "joint": {"class": "R", "axis": [0,1,0], "limits": ["-160 deg", "-30 deg"]}, "actuator": "qdd-l",
"transmission": {"belt": {"ratio": "2.35"}},
"body": {"region": {"capsule": ["0.02 m", "0.21 m"]}, "fill": {"shell": "1.5 mm"},
"material": "cfrp-ud"} },
{ "foot": {"region": {"sphere": "0.022 m"}, "fill": "solid", "material": "rubber-60a",
"contact": {"law": "foot-patch", "interface": "rubber-60a/default",
"torsion_radius": "8 mm"}} } ] },
"contract": {
"guarantees": { "mass": ["1.6 kg", "2.4 kg"], "port_inertia": "sym-psd-6",
"bus_demand": {"peak": "38 A", "profile": "per-task, time-resolved"},
"heat_to_sink": {"continuous_max": "60 W"} },
"assumes": { "bus_voltage": ["18 V", "25.2 V"], "sink_conductance_min": "0.4 W/K" },
"digest": "b3:9a4e…" } }
The port contract, read against L.1 (§14.6).
| Port | Kind | Effort and flow | What joining it to quad-tray checks |
|---|---|---|---|
mount |
mech |
Wrench and twist at hip_mount |
Twists identified in the common frame, wrenches balance; power positive into the module |
bus |
elec |
Voltage and current | The bus nominal of 22.2 V lies in the assumed [18, 25.2] V; currents balance at the node |
sink |
thermal |
Temperature and heat rate | Four modules each assume 0.4 W/K; the shared sink offers 1.6 W/K, so the assumption is met with nothing to spare |
state |
signal |
A typed message, 1,000 Hz, latency at most 1 ms | One producer, any number of typed consumers; carries no power |
sole |
contact |
Meets the world under the foot-patch law |
Listed because the module's effect on the robot cannot be summarized at its mount port alone |
Two readings of the contract are fixed by §14.6 and are easy to get wrong. First, four legs with a peak demand of 38 A each add to 152 A against a bus limit of 60 A, and that sum excludes nothing: a contract that carries only peaks can admit and cannot exclude, so the bus analysis of §15.10 runs on the time-resolved profiles before any design is excluded on electrical grounds. Second, the limb port packet is 27 scalars (a symmetric positive-semidefinite 6 × 6 inertia and a bias wrench) and does not describe a leg whose foot is in contact; contact couples every limb through the base. A leaf-local substitution of this module reuses the sibling legs' kernels and local analyses and invalidates static stability, the baseline controller, every rollout and every whole-robot certificate.
One field is not fixed by §14.6: how an entry of params names its target inside body. The specimen writes the
default values in place; a lever in a .fbot names its target by path.
L.3 An .ftask: kitchen tray delivery
Format FMT-FTASK, schema frob.task/1 (§24.4), shown in the S-expression view. §24.4 fixes the nine section names and
their contents and fixes the grammar of requirements; the keywords inside the other eight sections are proposals
confined to those contents. The TaskId is t:kitchen-tray@88c1….
(task "kitchen-tray" :schema "frob.task/1"
(interface
(ports (mech base) (elec bus) (payload tray))
(observation proprio-and-scan :frame base :rate 50 Hz
(joint-pos 12 rad) (joint-vel 12 rad/s) (base-gyro 3 rad/s) (gravity-dir 3 1)
(scan 64 m) (goal-vec 2 m) (sample-age 2 s))
(action joint-targets 12 rad :rate 50 Hz :law latent-then-limit))
(clocks
(physics 1/500 s :phase 0 s) (imu 1/500 s :phase 0 s) (policy 1/50 s :phase 0 s)
(lidar 1/10 s :phase 1/20 s) (req 1/50 s :phase 0 s))
(terms
(obs joint-pos :unit rad :noise encoder-14b :delay 1 ms :rep trivial)
(obs base-gyro :unit rad/s :noise imu-generic :delay 2 ms :rep pseudovector)
(obs scan :unit m :noise lidar-2d-generic :delay 30 ms :rep permutation)
(reward progress :unit 1/s :rep invariant) ; integrated over simulated time
(reward tray-calm :unit 1/s :rep invariant)
(terminate success :on (decided delivered satisfied))
(terminate failure :on (decided delivered violated)))
(signals
(dist_to_pass m :kind state :clock physics :reduce last)
(base_speed m/s :kind state :clock physics :reduce max)
(tilt deg :kind interval-extremum :clock physics :reduce max)
(tray_tilt deg :kind interval-extremum :clock physics :reduce max)
(tray_acc m/s^2 :kind interval-extremum :clock physics :reduce max)
(clearance_min m :kind interval-extremum :clock physics :reduce min)
(winding_temp_max K :kind state :clock physics :reduce max)
(spill_events 1 :kind count :clock physics :reduce last))
(requirements
(atom at-pass (>= (- 0.15 m dist_to_pass) 0 m) :scale 0.15 m)
(atom settled (>= (- 0.05 m/s base_speed) 0 m/s) :scale 0.05 m/s)
(atom upright (>= (- 12 deg tilt) 0 deg) :scale 12 deg)
(atom tray-level (>= (- 8 deg tray_tilt) 0 deg) :scale 8 deg)
(atom gentle (>= (- 3 m/s^2 tray_acc) 0 m/s^2) :scale 3 m/s^2)
(atom clear (> clearance_min 0 m) :scale 0.05 m)
(atom cool (>= (- 383 K winding_temp_max) 0 K) :scale 20 K)
(atom no-spill (= spill_events 0) :exact)
(online placed (H (0 s 1 s) (and at-pass settled tray-level)))
(online carrying (and upright tray-level gentle))
(verdict delivered (U (0 s 20 s) (and upright tray-level gentle clear cool no-spill) placed))
(example trace:b3:1c0a… satisfied) (example trace:b3:77e2… satisfied)
(example trace:b3:a04f… violated) (example trace:b3:5d19… violated))
(randomization
(draw floor-friction :from card:rubber-60a/tile:uncertainty :stream world.material)
(draw film :from registry:hazards/commercial-kitchen:wet-floor :stream world.film)
(draw closer-torque :from registry:hazards/commercial-kitchen:swing-door :stream world.fixture)
(draw tray-fill :from registry:hazards/commercial-kitchen:hot-liquid :stream world.payload)
(draw imu-bias :from card:imu-generic:uncertainty :stream sensor.imu))
(reset
(settled-pose :count 64 :speed-below 1e-3 :for 0.2 s :penetration-max 0.5 mm :first-impulse-within 5 %))
(world
(scenes :family kitchen-commercial/galley :split split:b3:60d3… :group-by building)
(horizon 22 s))
(study
(default :type fixed-n :n 64 :margin 0.05 :rule paired-clopper-pearson/1 :level 0.05)
(budget :gpu-s 600)))
What task.check establishes for this file (§24.5), each a refusal if it fails.
| Check | Here |
|---|---|
Every atom has a scale of its own dimension or is :exact |
Seven scaled atoms; no-spill is :exact on a count |
| Signals crossing clocks declare a reduction | Every signal is reduced from the 1/500 s physics clock to the 1/50 s requirement clock |
| Window bounds are multiples of the requirement period | 1 s and 20 s are 50 and 1,000 ticks of 1/50 s |
| Online signals are past-time | placed uses H; carrying is a conjunction of atoms |
| The horizon covers the reach of the verdict | Reach 20 s, horizon 22 s |
| Labelled examples exist and the monitors agree with them | Two satisfied and two violated traces |
| The mutation check | Reversing a comparator or deleting an atom changes at least one example's label |
The until-form says that the six carrying conditions hold at every tick before the tray is placed, and that placement
completes within 20 s. Placement cannot latch: H over 1 s is false the tick any of its three conditions lapses.
Margins are dimensionless: a tilt of 17.04° gives (12 − 17.04)/12 = −0.42 for upright, which is the binding atom of
the counterexample in L.6. The lidar clock at 1/10 s with a phase of 1/20 s is not an integer multiple of anything
else in the file and needs no special case (§20.4).
L.4 An .fmission query: which stances and knee ratios can carry the tray
Schema frob.mission/1 (§25.3.2). The query is static and exact: it asks for the designs that can hold the loaded
tray in a four-foot stance over the whole declared load envelope, with every foot inside its rating and every knee
inside its continuous torque. It does not ask whether the robot can walk; the task of L.3 and the studies that follow
ask that.
{
"schema": "frob.mission/1",
"name": "tray-stance-and-knee",
"verb": "mission.synthesize",
"design_domain": {
"family": "template:quad-mammal@1",
"topologies": ["rect4"],
"ports": ["foot.pp", "foot.pm", "foot.mp", "foot.mm"],
"isomorphisms": ["mirror-x", "mirror-y"],
"free": [
{ "name": "v", "meaning": "1 / half_width", "unit": "1/m", "chart": "inverse-length", "box": ["4", "12"] },
{ "name": "r", "meaning": "knee belt ratio", "unit": "1", "chart": "linear", "box": ["1", "5/2"] }
],
"bound": [
{ "name": "u", "meaning": "1 / half_length", "unit": "1/m", "value": "5" },
{ "name": "cap", "meaning": "normal-force rating per foot, port order", "unit": "N",
"value": ["88", "88", "88", "88"] },
{ "name": "lam", "meaning": "knee lever arm in the loaded crouch", "unit": "m", "value": "1/10" },
{ "name": "tau_c", "meaning": "continuous knee torque at the motor", "unit": "N*m", "value": "4" }
],
"tolerances": []
},
"world": {
"kind": "bounded-set",
"family": "static-tray-envelope@1",
"frame": { "origin": "footprint-centre", "axes": "x-forward, y-left, z-up", "handedness": "right" },
"parameters": [
{ "name": "W", "meaning": "total vertical load", "unit": "N", "value": "160" },
{ "name": "P", "meaning": "first moment (Σ xᵢ·fᵢ, Σ yᵢ·fᵢ) of the support forces", "unit": "N*m",
"hull": [["16", "12"], ["16", "-12"], ["-16", "12"], ["-16", "-12"]] }
],
"hidden": [],
"persistence": {}
},
"observation": {
"channel": "payload-wrench@1",
"fields": ["W", "P"],
"noise": "none",
"timing": { "arrival": "before-decision", "clock": "static" }
},
"policy_class": {
"kind": "causal",
"indexed_by": "nominal-design",
"authority": "independent-normal-force",
"randomization": "none",
"decision_makers": ["allocator"]
},
"horizon": { "kind": "static" },
"predicates": {
"accept": [
{ "id": "force-balance", "expr": "Σ fᵢ = W" },
{ "id": "moment-balance", "expr": "Σ qᵢ·fᵢ = P" },
{ "id": "unilateral", "expr": "fᵢ ≥ 0" },
{ "id": "rating", "expr": "fᵢ ≤ capᵢ" },
{ "id": "knee-hold", "expr": "lam·fᵢ ≤ r·tau_c" }
],
"hard_loss": [],
"margins": []
},
"quantifiers": [
{ "q": "exists", "var": "policy", "scope": "per-nominal-design" },
{ "q": "forall", "var": "world" },
{ "q": "forall", "var": "execution" }
],
"objective": { "minimize": "1 / v", "unit": "m", "claim": "minimum-with-matching-lower-bound" },
"evidence": { "profile": "exact", "arithmetic": "rational", "accept_classes": ["certified"] },
"resolution": { "max_unresolved": { "measure": "area-fraction", "chart": "v, r", "value": "1/4" },
"mandatory": ["interior", "exterior"] },
"response": ["inner", "excluded", "unresolved", "witnesses", "cost_bounds", "candidate_cost_gap",
"next_test", "certificate"],
"budget": { "wall_s": 60, "cpu_core_s": 60, "gpu_s": 0, "referee_s": 0, "checker_s": 10, "sync_wait_ms": 2000 }
}
The answer by hand. Order the feet [++, +−, −+, −−] at (±1/u, ±1/v). With α = P_x·u/4 and β = P_y·v/4, every allocation that balances force and both moments is
f = (W/4 + α + β + t, W/4 + α − β − t, W/4 − α + β − t, W/4 − α − β + t)
for one free scalar t. At the vertex P = (16, 12) N·m, W/4 = 40 N, α = 20 N and β = 3v N, so
f = (60 + 3v + t, 60 − 3v − t, 20 + 3v − t, 20 − 3v + t). The last foot cannot pull: f₋₋ ≥ 0 forces t ≥ 3v − 20, and
then f₊₊ ≥ 40 + 6v. Both rating and knee-hold bound f₊₊ from above, by 88 N and by r·τ_c/λ = 40·r N. Taking
t = 3v − 20 gives f = (40 + 6v, 80 − 6v, 40, 0), which is the witness family, affine in v. The same holds at the other
three vertices by the two mirrors. Hence:
a design (v, r) is feasible ⟺ 40 + 6v ≤ min(88, 40·r) ⟺ v ≤ 8 and r ≥ 1 + 3v/20.
The narrowest feasible body has v = 8, a half-width of 1/8 m, and needs r ≥ 11/5. At v = 8, r = 11/5 and P = (16, 12) the forces are (88, 32, 40, 0) N: they sum to 160 N, give Σ xᵢ·fᵢ = (1/5)·(88 + 32 − 40 − 0) = 16 N·m and Σ yᵢ·fᵢ = (1/8)·(88 − 32 + 40 − 0) = 12 N·m, and the knee torque is (1/10)·88 = 8.8 N·m against 2.2·4 = 8.8 N·m. In right-handed axes with +z upward the support torque is Σ rᵢ × (0, 0, fᵢ) = (P_y, −P_x, 0) = (12, −16, 0) N·m; a packet that passes (16, 12) directly as the torque must be rejected. The exclusion has a dual witness: with y = (0, ½, ½) on the three balance equations, yᵀA = (1, 0, 0, −1), so f₊₊ − f₋₋ = 40 + 6v on every balanced allocation, while f₊₊ − f₋₋ ≤ min(88, 40·r) on every admissible one.
What a first pass returns. The engine paves the box with cells and decides each from its corners, since feasibility is monotone (decreasing in v, increasing in r). With four cells in v and three in r:
| Cell | v | r | Worst corner feasible | Best corner feasible | Verdict | Proof |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| c:01 | [4, 6] | [1, 3/2] | No | No: 64 > 60 at (4, 3/2) | Excluded | lp-farkas, knee |
| c:02 | [4, 6] | (3/2, 2) | No | Yes | Unresolved: straddles the threshold | — |
| c:03 | [4, 6] | [2, 5/2] | Yes: 76 ≤ 80 at (6, 2) | Yes | Inner | lp-primal, affine in v |
| c:04 | (6, 8] | [1, 3/2] | No | No: more than 76 against 60 | Excluded | lp-farkas, knee |
| c:05 | (6, 8] | (3/2, 2) | No | Yes | Unresolved: straddles the threshold | — |
| c:06 | (6, 8] | [2, 5/2] | No: 88 > 80 at (8, 2) | Yes | Unresolved: straddles the threshold | — |
| c:07 to c:09 | (8, 10] | all three | No | No: more than 88 against 88 | Excluded | lp-farkas, rating |
| c:10 to c:12 | (10, 12] | all three | No | No | Excluded | lp-farkas, rating |
One inner cell, three unresolved, eight excluded. The outer set is the domain minus the excluded cells: c:02, c:03, c:05 and c:06. The unresolved area is 3 of 12 equal cells, which meets the declared resolution of 1/4. The objective is not yet settled: the best certified design has half-width 1/6 m, the outer set reaches 1/8 m, and the gap is 1/24 m, so the first answer is a feasible candidate with a gap and not a minimum. A refinement that splits c:06 at r = 11/5 makes c:06a = (6, 8] × [11/5, 5/2] inner (worst corner 88 ≤ 88) and leaves c:06b = (6, 8] × [2, 11/5) unresolved; the incumbent and the lower bound then meet at 1/8 m. The design of L.1 sits at the centre of c:06a, at v = 7 and r = 47/20, where the peak foot force is 82 N against 88 N and the knee torque 8.2 N·m against 9.4 N·m.
What the answer does not say. It is a Proof claim of class Certified about the declared model: independent control of the four normal forces, a load wrench observed before allocation, point feet, a static stance. Under equal passive springs the same body carries different forces, and the certificate does not transfer (§25.13). It says nothing about walking, slipping or the door.
L.5 An .fenergy budget: the stop at the pass counter
Schema frob.energy/1 (§22.11). The boundary is a bumper at the pass counter. The budget bounds the energy the robot
can deliver to that boundary during a stop, whatever the contact sequence and the friction.
{
"schema": "frob.energy/1",
"boundary": "pass_counter_stop",
"load_path": ["torso", "tray", "leg_fl", "leg_fr", "leg_rl", "leg_rr"],
"unit_scale": { "energy": "1e-6 J", "time": "1e-6 s" },
"terms": {
"kinetic_ub": { "mass_cap_kg": "18", "speed_error_mps": "0.02", "includes_reflected_inertia": true },
"drive": { "p_max_w": "40", "cutoff_delay_s": "0.030" },
"external": [{ "source": "gravity", "bound_j": "0.11", "basis": "slope <= 0.02 over 0.030 m" }],
"stored": [{ "source": "leg_series_compliance", "bound_j": "0.15" }],
"reserve_j": "0.10"
},
"absorber": { "card": "bumper-150N-30mm", "w_abs_j": "4.50", "provenance": "assumed" },
"premises": { "sources_complete": "port-graph-digest", "absorber_on_path": "declared-guide" },
"claim": { "class": "Estimated", "reality": "no-claim", "flags": "the no-authorization flags of §12" }
}
The arithmetic, at a monitor reading of 0.50 m/s at the boundary, in integers of 10⁻⁶ J.
| Term | Calculation | Value |
|---|---|---|
| T_ub | ½ · 18 kg · (0.50 + 0.02)² m²/s² | 2,433,600 |
| E_drive | 40 W · 0.030 s | 1,200,000 |
| E_ext | gravity: 18 · 9.81 · 0.030 · 0.02 = 0.106 J, bounded by 0.11 J | 110,000 |
| E_stored | leg series compliance | 150,000 |
| E_reserve | at least the ledger's residual bound over the window | 100,000 |
| Sum | 3,993,600 | |
| W_abs | 150 N over 30 mm | 4,500,000 |
The predicate 3,993,600 ≤ 4,500,000 holds with a margin of 506,400, that is 0.506 J. The longest admissible cutoff
delay is (4.50 − 2.4336 − 0.11 − 0.15 − 0.10) / 40 = 42.7 ms against the declared 30 ms. The claim is Estimated, not
Certified, because the absorber envelope is assumed: the arithmetic is exact and the weakest input sets the class.
One bench measurement of the bumper and one of the drive would raise it for every later policy on this hardware, since
no term depends on the policy. The budget answers an energy question. It supports no statement about peak force, about
clamping after the stop, or about contacts that bypass the bumper.
L.6 An .fmcw: a minimal counterexample world of three edits
Format FMT-FMCW, schema frob.mcw/1 (§26.7). nemesis.shrink reduced a failing world of seven edits to three. Remove
any one and the tray is delivered.
{ "schema": "frob.mcw/1", "id": "w:3fa9…", "task": "t:kitchen-tray@88c1…", "requirement": "delivered",
"candidate": {"model": "m:5d20…", "controller": "c:2be8…", "policy": "p:6f1a…"},
"base": {"scene": "s:kitchen-17@a4e0…", "world": {"run_seed": 901, "world": 5120, "episode": 3}},
"edits": [
{"op": "set", "path": "/floor/patch[galley-2]/film", "from": "dry", "to": "grease", "changes": ["material"]},
{"op": "set", "path": "/fixtures/door[pass]/closer_torque", "from": "14 N·m", "to": "19 N·m",
"changes": ["fixture"]},
{"op": "set", "path": "/payloads/tray/fill", "from": "0.50", "to": "0.80", "changes": ["payload"]} ],
"minimality": {"kind": "1-minimal", "pairs_exhausted": true, "tests": 42, "seeds_failing": "55/64"},
"failure": {"class": "slip", "binding_atom": "upright", "margin": -0.42, "time_s": "11.3"},
"replay": {"backend": "gpu-cuda", "class": "D2", "state_digests": "b3:0c55…"},
"promotion": {"tier": "referee", "reproduced": true,
"variants": ["half-step", "iterations-x2", "law-2", "tol-div-10"]},
"oracle": {"class": "solvable-causal", "controller": "c:77e1…", "margin": 0.18, "trace": "b3:a9d2…"},
"legality": {"inside": true, "touched": [{"bound": "closer_torque", "provenance": "assumed"},
{"bound": "tray_fill", "provenance": "assumed"}]},
"prior": {"log10_density_ratio": -4.6},
"neighbours_passing": ["w:51b0…", "w:e7c4…", "w:0a9d…"],
"evidence": {"class": "Tested", "tier": "referee", "standing": "established"},
"authorization": {"execution_authorized": false, "hardware_safety_signoff": false,
"sim_to_real_certified": false} }
How to read it.
- Three edits, three mechanisms. A grease film on one floor patch, a swing door that closes harder, and a fuller tray. Each edit declares the aspect of the scene it changes, so each can serve as one intervention in L.9.
- Minimal means 1-minimal. Removing any single edit loses the failure; the three passing neighbours are those worlds. The original list had seven edits, so every subset of one or two was also tested (7 + 21 = 28 of the 42 tests): no single edit and no pair fails, and this world is minimum among pairs. It is not called the closest failure.
- The failure is the same failure. A subset counts only if it violates the same atom (
upright) with the same class (slip) on at least 48 of 64 paired seeds; here 55. - It is not an artifact of the fast tier. The failure reproduces on the referee and under four numerical variants.
- It is not an impossible world. The oracle found a causal controller that delivers the tray in this world with a margin of 0.18, so the world is solvable and the failure belongs to the candidate.
- Two of its bounds are
assumed. The closer torque and the fill level sit inside the legality profile, at values whose ranges no cited norm supports (Appendix G.3). A report says so. - It carries what replays it. A file that does not replay with identical digests on its originating backend is invalid.
L.7 A .frobcert bundle listing
Schema frob.cert/1 (§12.4). frob-lemma wrote the bundle from the plain proof objects of the mission answer and the
qualification receipt. The listing is what prove.list prints for it; each row is one claim that frob-verify
re-checks with the standard library alone.
| Entry | Claim kind | Class | Domain | Bundle proof kind | Proof object | Payload | Expected |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| e1 | family-inclusion |
Certified | c:03: v ∈ [4, 6], r ∈ [2, 5/2] | lp-primal |
p0, lp-primal |
Forces affine in v at four load vertices, checked at v = 4 and v = 6 | accept |
| e2 | family-inclusion |
Certified | c:06a: v ∈ (6, 8], r ∈ [11/5, 5/2] | lp-primal |
p4, lp-primal |
The same family, checked at v = 6 and v = 8 | accept |
| e3 | family-exclusion |
Certified | c:01, c:04: v ∈ [4, 8], r ∈ [1, 3/2] | lp-farkas |
p1, lp-farkas |
y = (0, ½, ½); 40 + 6v > 40·r on the cells, least gap 4 N at (4, 3/2) | accept |
| e4 | family-exclusion |
Certified | c:07 to c:12: v ∈ (8, 12], every r | lp-farkas |
p2, lp-farkas |
y = (0, ½, ½); 40 + 6v > 88 for v > 8 | accept |
| e5 | partition |
Certified | The whole box [4, 12] × [1, 5/2] | partition |
p3, partition |
Thirteen cells; union equals the box; interiors disjoint; open and closed ends as listed | accept |
| e6 | qualification-receipt |
Tested | Campaign q:kitchen-tray/1, index 1 |
sample-coverage |
— | 2 failures of 200 sealed clusters; bound 0.0357 at α₁ = 0.025; levels spent 0.025 of 0.05 | accept |
Entry e2 in full, in the container form of §12.4. A cell with two coordinates lists one rational per coordinate in
lo and hi.
{
"schema": "frob.cert/1",
"claim": { "kind": "family-inclusion", "class": "Certified",
"quantifiers": ["exists_causal_policy_per_design", "forall_admitted_worlds",
"forall_admitted_executions"], "horizon": "static" },
"query": { "blake3": "b3:3c9d…", "bytes": "…the canonical bytes of L.4…" },
"definitions": { "units": "SI", "frame": "footprint centre, +x forward, +y left, +z up", "clocks": [],
"ports_ordered": ["++", "+-", "-+", "--"] },
"assumptions": [ { "id": "authority", "value": "independent normal forces", "survives": "grow" },
{ "id": "world-set", "blake3": "b3:e17a…", "survives": "shrink" } ],
"plant": { "model": "template:quad-mammal@1 with u = 5, cap = 88 N, lam = 1/10 m, tau_c = 4 N·m",
"policy_class": "causal, indexed by nominal design, no randomization" },
"domain": { "chart": "v = 1/half_width in 1/m; r = knee belt ratio",
"cell": { "lo": [["6", "1"], ["11", "5"]], "hi": [["8", "1"], ["5", "2"]] } },
"proof": { "kind": "lp-primal",
"primitive_equations": ["sum f = W", "sum x·f = P_x", "sum y·f = P_y", "0 <= f <= c",
"lam·f <= r·tau_c"],
"payload": { "vertices": 4,
"argument": "forces affine in v; feasibility convex in the load; monotone in r",
"forces_newton_at_v8": [ [["88","1"], ["32","1"], ["40","1"], ["0","1"]],
[["32","1"], ["88","1"], ["0","1"], ["40","1"]],
[["40","1"], ["0","1"], ["88","1"], ["32","1"]],
[["0","1"], ["40","1"], ["32","1"], ["88","1"]] ],
"forces_newton_at_v6": [ [["76","1"], ["44","1"], ["40","1"], ["0","1"]],
[["44","1"], ["76","1"], ["0","1"], ["40","1"]],
[["40","1"], ["0","1"], ["76","1"], ["44","1"]],
[["0","1"], ["40","1"], ["44","1"], ["76","1"]] ] } },
"checker": { "name": "frob-verify", "build": "…" },
"expected_verdict": "accept",
"lineage": { "merkle_root": "b3:d4a9…", "alpha_spend": [] },
"authorization": { "execution_authorized": false, "hardware_safety_signoff": false, "sim_to_real_certified": false }
}
What the auditor recomputes for e2: at each of the eight listed force vectors, the vertical sum (160 N), both first moments against the vertex (±16, ±12) N·m at the stated v, every capacity (at most 88 N) and every knee bound at the worst ratio of the cell (88·(1/10) = 8.8 ≤ (11/5)·4 = 8.8 N·m); that the forces are affine in v between the two ends, so the checks at v = 6 and v = 8 cover the cell; that the four vertices span the declared load hull; that the lower end in v is open as the partition entry says; and that the information the allocator is assumed to have is in the observation contract. Mutations that must each cause rejection: a swapped foot order with unchanged forces; (16, 12) passed as the torque; an unreported positive force floor; a passive-authority tag; a cell end certified closed where the partition lists it open; a flag missing or true.
Two notes on spelling. The mission answer names its proofs by the kinds of §25.5.2 and the bundle by the kinds of
§12.4; the correspondence is in Appendix I.4. §12.4 writes one claim per bundle file, while a mission answer cites one
bundle hash; here the per-claim entries share one lineage.merkle_root, and that root is the hash the answer cites.
The payload keys argument, forces_newton_at_v8 and forces_newton_at_v6 extend the one-vertex forces_newton of
the specimen in §12.4 to a cell.
L.8 A study plan
A fixed-n exact study comparing the design before and after the foot edit of L.9 on the task of L.3. §32.6.1 and
§24.12 fix what a plan binds (designs, scene, task, seed protocol, budget, backend, one study type, and for fixed-n
the pre-analysis); no chapter prints the fields of frob.plan/1, so the spellings below are proposals confined to
those contents. This is the result of study.plan; planning runs no physics.
{ "schema": "frob.plan/1", "plan": "plan:b3:52e8…",
"question": "B delivers the tray more often than A by more than 0.05",
"designs": { "A": "d:7a3e…", "B": "d:c05b…" },
"controller_arm": "shared: baseline controller re-synthesized per design, equal resources",
"task": "t:kitchen-tray@88c1…", "requirement": "delivered",
"scenes": { "family": "kitchen-commercial/galley", "split": "split:b3:60d3…", "part": "development" },
"seed_protocol": { "pair_by": ["world", "replicate"], "unit": "building", "addresses": "philox:plan-key" },
"backend": "strict:gpu-cuda", "determinism": "D2", "promote_to": "referee",
"study": { "type": "fixed-n", "n": 64, "margin": "0.05", "level": "0.05",
"rule": "paired-clopper-pearson/1" },
"preanalysis": { "outcomes": 2145,
"reachable": { "promote": 521, "inferior": 521, "inconclusive": 1103 },
"unreachable": ["practical-tie"],
"note": "perfect concordance gives [-0.0662, +0.0662]; a tie first becomes reachable at n = 86",
"least_b_at_a_0": 15, "hash": "b3:5d10…" },
"estimate": { "gpu_s": 96, "interval_90": [78, 121], "referee_cpu_core_s": 410 },
"budget": { "gpu_s": 150, "cpu_core_s": 600 } }
How the plan is read and used.
- The type is declared and kept. A fixed-n study computes its verdict once, at 64 complete pairs. No e-process may stop it; it may stop early only when every completion of the unresolved pairs gives the same verdict.
- The pre-analysis is the reason to plan before spending. With 64 pairs and a five-point margin there are
C(66, 2) = 2,145 outcomes. A practical tie is unreachable, because even perfect concordance leaves the interval
[−0.0662, +0.0662]. A request that named "tie" among its verdicts would be refused (
FROB-REF-532). - The unit is the building. Episodes that share a building share a generator draw, so pairs are formed per building and the 64 units are 64 buildings.
- Pairing needs a controlled determinism class. Both arms run at D2 on one backend; under an uncontrolled class the paired statistic is refused.
- The submitted object cannot drift.
study.submittakes the plan address and an idempotency key.
A result consistent with the plan, from study.compare: b = 19 pairs where only B delivers, a = 2 where only A does,
40 where both do, 3 where neither does, none unscored; 19 + 2 + 40 + 3 + 0 = 64. The simultaneous interval on the
difference of discordant probabilities is [0.0554, 0.4392]; its lower end exceeds 0.05, so the rule promotes B and
study.compare reports the metric as settled. The result stays provisional until it is promoted to the referee.
It is a development result. It is not a qualification.
L.9 An agent session over MCP
One agent, one session, the tools of six task clusters. Requests are tools/call with the tool name and its
arguments; responses are the structuredContent of the result, which is the envelope frob.envelope/1, abridged to
the fields that matter at each step. The token arrives from the environment (stdio transport, §32.12.9). Argument names
follow the CLI flags of §32.16 and §27.12. Tool names are those of the task clusters of §32.12.4; where one is an
alias, the registry verb of Appendix J.4 produces the result.
── orient ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
→ tools/list
← session_focus, job_wait, job_cancel (base tools, always listed)
capabilities, doctor, robot_docs, schema, design_templates, scene_list, session_show (cluster orient)
→ session_show {}
← { "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "session": "s:2f6a…", "namespace": "agent-17", "focus": "orient",
"scopes": ["design:write", "mission:run", "nemesis:run", "autopsy:run", "sim:run", "qual:run"],
"budget": { "gpu_s_left": 1800, "cpu_core_s_left": 7200 } } }
── mission ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
→ session_focus { "cluster": "mission" }
← { "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "focus": "mission",
"tools": ["mission_new", "mission_check", "mission_synthesize", "mission_refute",
"mission_distinguish", "mission_show", "result_revalidate"] } }
→ mission_new { "document": "…the .fmission of L.4…", "idempotency_key": "mis-1" }
← { "verb": "mission.new", "ok": true, "exit": 0, "result": { "mission_id": "q:3c9d…" },
"bound": { "family": "template:quad-mammal@1#b3:8e02…" } }
→ mission_check { "mission": "q:3c9d…" }
← { "verb": "mission.check", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "domain": "nonempty", "topologies": 1, "free": ["v", "r"],
"quantifiers": "∃ policy per nominal design, ∀ worlds, ∀ executions",
"fragment": "linear static: exact answer available", "horizon": "static" } }
→ mission_synthesize { "mission": "q:3c9d…", "estimate_only": true }
← { "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "estimate": { "admission_s": 0.01, "lowering_s": 0.01, "proposing_s": 0.02, "checker_s": 0.02,
"cpu_core_s": 0.06, "interval_90": [0.04, 0.2], "gpu_s": 0 } } }
→ mission_synthesize { "mission": "q:3c9d…", "idempotency_key": "syn-1",
"budget": { "cpu_core_s": 60, "checker_s": 10 }, "sync_wait_ms": 2000 }
← { "schema": "frob.envelope/1", "verb": "mission.synthesize", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": {
"mission_id": "q:3c9d…", "answer": "a:0e51…",
"inner": [ { "cell": "c:03", "topology": "rect4", "chart": "v, r", "box": [["4", "6"], ["2", "5/2"]],
"closed": [[true, true], [true, true]],
"policy": "selectable-per-nominal-design", "proofs": ["p0"] } ],
"excluded": [ { "cell": "c:01", "box": [["4", "6"], ["1", "3/2"]], "proofs": ["p1"],
"binding": "knee-hold at foot.pp under P = (16, 12) N*m" },
{ "cell": "c:04", "box": [["6", "8"], ["1", "3/2"]],
"closed": [[false, true], [true, true]], "proofs": ["p1"],
"binding": "knee-hold at foot.pp under P = (16, 12) N*m" },
{ "cell": "c:07", "box": [["8", "10"], ["1", "3/2"]],
"closed": [[false, true], [true, true]], "proofs": ["p2"],
"binding": "rating at foot.pp under P = (16, 12) N*m" }
/* c:08 to c:12 likewise, each excluded by proof p2 */ ],
"unresolved": [ { "cell": "c:02", "box": [["4", "6"], ["3/2", "2"]], "explanation": "straddles-threshold" },
{ "cell": "c:05", "box": [["6", "8"], ["3/2", "2"]], "explanation": "straddles-threshold" },
{ "cell": "c:06", "box": [["6", "8"], ["2", "5/2"]], "explanation": "straddles-threshold" } ],
"witnesses": [ { "proof": "p0", "kind": "lp-primal", "vertex": ["16", "12"],
"forces_N": ["76", "44", "40", "0"], "at": { "v": "6", "r": "2" } } ],
"cost_bounds": { "incumbent": "1/6", "lower_bound": "1/8", "unit": "m", "attained": false, "gap": "1/24" },
"next_test": { "kind": "split-cell", "cell": "c:06", "at": { "r": "11/5" },
"why": "the lower bound on half-width is reached only inside c:06" },
"certificate": { "bundle": "b3:61f0…", "kinds": ["lp-primal", "lp-farkas", "partition"],
"checker": "frob-verify/1" },
"assumptions": ["independent-normal-force authority", "payload wrench observed before allocation",
"point feet, coplanar, static", "cap, lam and tau_c are stipulated by the query"] },
"evidence": { "class": "Certified", "tier": "static", "determinism": "exact",
"claims": ["Proof"], "reality": "no-claim" },
"cost": { "wall_ms": 41, "cpu_core_s": 0.05, "gpu_s": 0 },
"budget": { "gpu_s_left": 1800, "cpu_core_s_left": 7199.95 },
"warnings": [ "objective: claimed minimum not established; reported as feasible-candidate with gap 1/24 m" ],
"authorization": { "execution_authorized": false, "hardware_safety_signoff": false,
"sim_to_real_certified": false },
"next_actions": [ { "command": "frob mission synthesize q:3c9d… --strategy refine --from a:0e51…",
"why": "Splitting c:06 at r = 11/5 settles the minimum half-width." } ] }
→ mission_show { "mission": "q:3c9d…", "answer": "a:0e51…", "set": "outer" }
← { "verb": "mission.show", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "set": "outer", "definition": "domain minus excluded cells",
"cells": ["c:02", "c:03", "c:05", "c:06"], "measure": { "area_fraction": "1/3" },
"inner_within": ["c:03"], "unresolved_within": ["c:02", "c:05", "c:06"] } }
→ mission_synthesize { "mission": "q:3c9d…", "strategy": "refine", "from": "a:0e51…",
"idempotency_key": "syn-2", "sync_wait_ms": 2000 }
← { "verb": "mission.synthesize", "ok": true, "exit": 2,
"result": {
"answer": "a:8b27…", "refines": "a:0e51…",
"inner": [ { "cell": "c:03", "box": [["4", "6"], ["2", "5/2"]], "proofs": ["p0"] },
{ "cell": "c:06a", "box": [["6", "8"], ["11/5", "5/2"]],
"closed": [[false, true], [true, true]], "proofs": ["p4"] } ],
"unresolved": [ { "cell": "c:02" }, { "cell": "c:05" },
{ "cell": "c:06b", "box": [["6", "8"], ["2", "11/5"]],
"closed": [[false, true], [true, false]], "explanation": "straddles-threshold" } ],
"witnesses": [ { "proof": "p4", "kind": "lp-primal", "vertex": ["16", "12"],
"forces_N": ["88", "32", "40", "0"], "at": { "v": "8", "r": "11/5" } } ],
"cost_bounds": { "incumbent": "1/8", "lower_bound": "1/8", "unit": "m", "attained": true, "gap": "0" },
"next_test": null,
"certificate": { "bundle": "b3:d4a9…", "kinds": ["lp-primal", "lp-farkas", "partition"],
"checker": "frob-verify/1" } },
"evidence": { "class": "Certified", "tier": "static", "determinism": "exact",
"claims": ["Proof"], "reality": "no-claim" },
"warnings": [ "boundary design has zero reserve at foot.pp (rating, knee-hold) and at foot.mm (unilateral)" ],
"next_actions": [ { "command": "frob design new quad-tray --from-cell q:3c9d…/c:06a",
"why": "The centre of c:06a keeps 6 N of force reserve and 1.2 N·m of knee reserve." } ] }
→ mission_refute { "mission": "q:3c9d…", "design": { "v": "9", "r": "5/2" } }
← { "verb": "mission.refute", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "verdict": "excluded for every allocation", "proof": "p2", "kind": "lp-farkas",
"binding": "rating at foot.pp: 94 N required, 88 N rated",
"smallest_relaxing_change": [ { "change": "cap", "to": "94 N" },
{ "change": "P_y envelope", "to": "32/3 N*m" } ] } }
── author ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
→ session_focus { "cluster": "author" }
→ design_new { "name": "quad-tray", "from_cell": "q:3c9d…/c:06a", "idempotency_key": "des-1" }
← { "verb": "design.new", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "design": "d:7a3e…", "at": { "v": "7", "r": "47/20" }, "half_width": "1/7 m",
"symmetry": { "mech": "C2xC2", "obs": "C2" } } } (the .fbot of L.1)
→ design_check { "design": "quad-tray" }
← { "verb": "design.check", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "closure": "closed", "symmetry": "C2xC2", "findings": [] },
"evidence": { "class": "Tested", "tier": "static", "model_id": "m:5d20…", "determinism": "exact",
"claims": [], "reality": "no-claim" }, "bound": { "design": "d:7a3e…" } }
→ control_synth { "design": "quad-tray", "idempotency_key": "ctl-1" }
← { "verb": "control.synth", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "controller": "c:2be8…", "gait": "trot from the atlas", "standing": "baseline" } }
── attack ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
→ session_focus { "cluster": "attack" }
→ nemesis_search { "design": "quad-tray", "task": "t:kitchen-tray@88c1…", "legality": "kitchen-commercial/default",
"budget": { "gpu_s": 240 }, "idempotency_key": "nem-1", "sync_wait_ms": 5000 }
← { "verb": "nemesis.search", "ok": true, "exit": 8,
"job": { "id": "j:77c0…", "state": "running", "progress": { "done": 512, "total": 4096, "unit": "worlds" },
"eta_s": 190, "poll_after_ms": 5000, "last_committed": "tick 10000" },
"next_actions": [ { "command": "job_wait j:77c0…", "why": "Accepted and still running." } ] }
→ job_wait { "job": "j:77c0…", "sync_wait_ms": 30000 } (repeated until the job completes)
← { "verb": "nemesis.search", "ok": true, "exit": 2,
"result": { "worlds_searched": 4096, "failures_promoted": 3, "classes": { "slip": 2, "timeout": 1 },
"baseline_arm": { "method": "random within the profile", "failures_at_equal_budget": 1 },
"worst": { "world": "w:9d04…", "run": "r:19e2…", "requirement": "delivered",
"binding_atom": "upright", "margin": -0.42, "edits": 7 },
"artifact_guard": "all three reproduce on the referee" },
"evidence": { "class": "Tested", "tier": "referee", "determinism": "D2", "claims": [], "reality": "no-claim" },
"cost": { "gpu_s": 212 }, "budget": { "gpu_s_left": 1588, "cpu_core_s_left": 7140 } }
→ nemesis_shrink { "world": "w:9d04…", "idempotency_key": "shr-1", "sync_wait_ms": 30000 }
← { "verb": "nemesis.shrink", "ok": true, "exit": 2,
"result": { "mcw": "w:3fa9…", "edits": 3, "minimality": "1-minimal; minimum among pairs", "tests": 42,
"seeds_failing": "55/64", "oracle": "solvable-causal",
"neighbours_passing": ["w:51b0…", "w:e7c4…", "w:0a9d…"] }, (the .fmcw of L.6)
"cost": { "gpu_s": 61 }, "budget": { "gpu_s_left": 1527, "cpu_core_s_left": 7140 } }
── diagnose ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
→ session_focus { "cluster": "simulate" }
→ run_fork { "run": "r:19e2…", "world": "w:3fa9…", "before": "failure", "dt": "1.0 s", "classify_only": true }
← { "verb": "run.fork", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "fork": "f:a41c…", "tick": "10.30 s", "null_replay": "bitwise",
"double_precision": "decision-equivalent",
"classified": [
{ "do": "scene./floor/patch[galley-2]/film := dry", "class": "contact-affecting",
"earliest_valid_tick": "10.30 s" },
{ "do": "scene./fixtures/door[pass]/closer_torque := 14 N·m", "class": "exogenous",
"earliest_valid_tick": "10.30 s" },
{ "do": "payload.tray.fill := 0.50", "class": "structural", "earliest_valid_tick": "0 s",
"forced_by": ["payload mass and slosh state", "policy history", "contact memory"] } ] } }
→ session_focus { "cluster": "diagnose" }
→ autopsy_intervene { "fork": "f:a41c…", "placebo": 64, "replicates": 8, "coalitions": "pairs",
"do": [ "scene./floor/patch[galley-2]/film := dry",
"scene./fixtures/door[pass]/closer_torque := 14 N·m",
"payload.tray.fill := 0.50" ],
"idempotency_key": "aut-1", "sync_wait_ms": 30000 }
← { "verb": "autopsy.intervene", "ok": true, "exit": 2, "result": { "fork": "f:a41c…", "forks_run": 113 } }
→ autopsy_attribute { "fork": "f:a41c…" }
← { "verb": "autopsy.attribute", "ok": true, "exit": 2,
"result": {
"schema": "frob.autopsy.attribution/1", "fork": "f:a41c…", "tier": "batch-cpu", "precision": "f64",
"horizon_s": "2", "forks_run": 113, "null_replay": "bitwise",
"placebo": { "n": 64, "flips": 2, "rate": 0.031, "separation_growth": "1.8e4" },
"contrasts": [
{ "do": "scene./floor/patch[galley-2]/film := dry", "class": "contact-affecting", "rescued": "8/8",
"contrast": 0.97, "flip_rate": { "1e-12": 0.0, "1e-7": 0.0 }, "label": "alternative" },
{ "do": "scene./fixtures/door[pass]/closer_torque := 14 N·m", "class": "exogenous", "rescued": "7/8",
"contrast": 0.84, "flip_rate": { "1e-12": 0.0, "1e-7": 0.125 }, "label": "alternative" } ],
"pairs": [ { "do": ["film := dry", "closer_torque := 14 N·m"], "rescued": "8/8", "interaction": -0.84 } ],
"refused": [ { "do": "payload.tray.fill := 0.50", "code": "FROB-REF-581",
"earliest_valid_fork_tick": 0 } ],
"evidence": { "class": "Estimated", "scope": "cause in the model at this tier, among the listed factors" },
"next_actions": [
{ "command": "frob autopsy rerun r:19e2… --edit 'set-param foot.radius 0.030 m' --worlds failing,sample:64",
"why": "Neither rescuing factor is the robot's to change; a design parameter is tested from the start." } ] },
"cost": { "cpu_core_s": 840 }, "budget": { "gpu_s_left": 1527, "cpu_core_s_left": 6300 } }
── author, then mission ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
→ session_focus { "cluster": "author" }
→ design_edit { "design": "quad-tray", "edit": "set-param",
"path": "/limbs/of/of/chain/3/foot/region/sphere", "value": "0.030 m",
"expected_parent": "d:7a3e…", "idempotency_key": "ed-1" }
← { "verb": "design.edit", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "design": "d:c05b…", "parent": "d:7a3e…", "symmetry": "preserved",
"invalidated": ["settled poses", "baseline controller", "every rollout", "contact binding"] } }
→ session_focus { "cluster": "mission" }
→ result_revalidate { "design": "quad-tray", "since": "d:7a3e…", "idempotency_key": "rev-1" }
← { "verb": "result.revalidate", "ok": true, "exit": 2,
"result": { "inherited": [ { "result": "a:8b27…",
"why": "reads half-width, knee ratio and ratings; the foot is outside its read set" },
{ "count": 8, "kind": "static analyses that do not read the foot region" } ],
"invalidated": [ { "count": 4, "kind": "dynamic verdicts and the counterexample replay",
"field": "foot region" } ],
"reruns": { "count": 4, "estimate_gpu_s": 37 } } }
── attack again ────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
→ session_focus { "cluster": "attack" }
→ nemesis_search { "design": "quad-tray", "task": "t:kitchen-tray@88c1…", "legality": "kitchen-commercial/default",
"budget": { "gpu_s": 240 }, "idempotency_key": "nem-2", "sync_wait_ms": 30000 }
← { "verb": "nemesis.search", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "worlds_searched": 4096, "failures_promoted": 0,
"note": "none found inside the profile; this is a search result and not a certificate" },
"cost": { "gpu_s": 240 }, "budget": { "gpu_s_left": 1287, "cpu_core_s_left": 6300 } }
── qualify ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
→ session_focus { "cluster": "qualify" }
→ eval_qualify { "design": "quad-tray", "task": "t:kitchen-tray@88c1…",
"claim": "failure probability of `delivered` at most 0.05", "dry": true }
← { "verb": "eval.qualify", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "campaign": "q:kitchen-tray/1", "index_if_committed": 1, "alpha_total": "0.05",
"alpha_i": "0.05/2", "clusters": 200,
"preanalysis": { "rule": "one-sided exact binomial bound", "qualified_reachable_with_failures_at_most": 3,
"bounds": { "3": 0.0432, "4": 0.0504 } },
"note": "nothing was committed and no level was spent" } }
→ eval_qualify { "design": "quad-tray", "task": "t:kitchen-tray@88c1…",
"claim": "failure probability of `delivered` at most 0.05",
"idempotency_key": "qual-1", "sync_wait_ms": 30000 }
← { "verb": "eval.qualify", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "schema": "frob.qualify.receipt/1", "campaign": "q:kitchen-tray/1", "index": 1,
"alpha_i": "0.05/2", "alpha_spent": "0.05*1/2", "decision": "promoted", "units_used": 200,
"sealed_until_close": ["world addresses", "per-unit outcomes", "telemetry", "stills"],
"receipt_hash": "b3:e2a0…",
"authorization": { "execution_authorized": false, "hardware_safety_signoff": false,
"sim_to_real_certified": false } },
"evidence": { "class": "Tested", "tier": "referee", "determinism": "D2",
"claims": ["Design comparison"], "reality": "no-claim" } }
→ prove_bundle { "design": "quad-tray", "mission": "q:3c9d…", "receipt": "b3:e2a0…",
"out": "quad-tray.frobcert", "idempotency_key": "cb-1" }
← { "verb": "prove.bundle", "ok": true, "exit": 0,
"result": { "bundle": "b3:d4a9…", "entries": 6, "in_tree_check": "accept" }, (the listing of L.7)
"authorization": { "execution_authorized": false, "hardware_safety_signoff": false,
"sim_to_real_certified": false } }
── offline, on a machine with neither the agent, a GPU nor the simulator ───────────────────────────────
$ frob-verify quad-tray.frobcert
accept 6 of 6 entries; class of the bundle: Tested (weakest entry e6); all three authorization flags false
What the session shows, as rules and not as illustrations.
- Seven tools at a time. The agent changes focus eight times and never sees more than seven task tools and three base tools. Focus changes what is listed, not what is permitted: the token's scopes are fixed at the first call.
- Inner and outer sets are different answers. The inner set holds the cells with a constructive witness; the outer set is the domain minus what was excluded. The agent builds from an inner cell and treats the three unresolved cells as work, not as candidates.
- A minimum needs a matching lower bound. The first answer is reported as a feasible candidate with a gap of 1/24 m. Only the refined answer, in which incumbent and lower bound meet at 1/8 m, states a minimum, and it warns that the boundary design has no reserve. The agent takes the cell centre.
- A long tool returns a handle. The first search returns exit 8 with a job, a denominator and a poll interval;
job_waitholds it with bounded waits. A dropped connection would be recovered withjob.findand the keynem-1: one job and one charge exist, or none do. - A certified static answer does not make the robot walk. The search finds three failing worlds for a design that lies inside a certified cell. The two facts are about different claims, and the envelope of each says which.
- A counterexample is shrunk before it is argued about. Seven edits become three, with passing neighbours and a solvability witness.
- Attribution is interventional and labelled. Two single interventions each rescue the run, so both are labelled
alternative; the placebo flips 2 of 64 forks, well under the 0.2 threshold above which nothing is named. The fill level is a property the payload carried from the first tick, so an intervention on it at the fork is refused with the earliest valid tick, zero. The attribution isEstimatedand is a cause in the model. - An edit puts evidence in question, by read set. The mission answer survives the foot edit because it never read the foot region; four dynamic results do not.
- "None found" is not a certificate. The second search says so in its result.
- Qualification spends error budget. The dry run shows the level α₁ = 0.05/2 and what is reachable: at 200
sealed clusters the one-sided exact bound admits at most 3 failures (0.0432 at 3, 0.0504 at 4). The committed
request observes 2 failures, bound 0.0357, and is promoted. A second submission would run at α₂ = 0.05/6 and
admit at most 2 (0.0425 at 2, 0.0505 at 3), so a retry costs power. The agent receives a receipt and nothing per
world, and no scope in its token can read the sealed clusters before the campaign closes (
FROB-REF-840). - The weakest input sets the class. The bundle holds five Certified entries and one Tested receipt; the product is Tested. Every exported object carries the three flags, all false: the bundle authorizes nothing.